The Real Deal New York

Building in Park Slope a cut above: Architecture review

470 Fourth Avenue has a certain charm -- which puts it way ahead of what it's replacing

March 17, 2014 09:40AM
By James Gardner

  • Print
470-fourth

470 Fourth Avenue in Brooklyn

Quite a nice building will soon start to go up in Park Slope, at 470 Fourth Avenue. The 12,690-square-foot site, which currently contains several entirely undistinguished and relatively recent row houses, was purchased for $20 million by Adam America Real Estate Group, Slate Property Group and Naveh Shuster Limited.

According to recently unveiled renderings, this mixed-use rental building, which will be between 12 and 14 stories and provide space for shops at ground level, has been conceived in a generally modernist style with elements of the deconstructivist idiom scattered here and there about its façade. The building can be read as an International Style slab: slightly taller than it is broad, with horizontal infill and vertical coursing lines that seek to define its interior structural divisions.

But around this slab a carapace of brilliant red brick seems to have accumulated, and this is what invests the building with interest. The brick surface, which is solid as it recedes from the avenue, becomes spottier and more immaterial along the avenue itself. In some places, as though embracing the arbitrariness of the deconstructivist idiom, the brick seems to lie flat against the curtainwall, while at other points its protrudes from it, creating an almost old-fashioned effect of punched windows. Over all, the building promises to be well-proportioned and well-made.

The building will not be the first large development along Fourth Avenue, but it will represent yet another challenge to the generally low lying row houses in the neighborhood, some of which are lovely and fully deserve to be protected. Striking a balance between the interests of development while still preserving the character of the neighborhood is a complicated consideration. It is one that certainly applies here. In any case, the neighborhood can take solace in the thought that the building that is set to go up is better than the ones it will replace.

  • ccg718

    This building is on the Gowanus side of 4th Ave, not Park Slope. And it is not nice.

  • guess

    this review is a joke. building will look like every other piece of crap.

  • Blossom29

    How could the author think this monstrosity is a good thing? We can only hope the city makes them scale it back to something less gross.

    Eleventh Street and Fourth Avenue used to be called the South Slope and is now considered Gowanus. Whatever the name, the building is too big for the neighborhood, it’s a hideous slab, will cut out light for all the houses on 11th and 10th Streets, and is another example of how Amanda Burden’s plan for the South Slope was misguided and destructive, and totally in favor of developers. Off with their heads.

  • Susan

    Has a certain charm? Is better than what it’s replacing? The author is an ass. Perhaps he didn’t like the style of the houses this hideous thing is replacing, but they were low-scale and appropriate for the neighborhood. And that’s a big consideration. I hope some developer comes along and blocks out his light and air; maybe his opinion will evolve.

MENU