Commission rebates could entice NJ buyers to take the plunge

January 23, 2009 11:15AM
Gov. Jon Corzine

 
Legislation pending in the New Jersey Legislature would allow brokers to offer rebates to Garden State buyers.

The bill, passed last week by the State Assembly's regulated professions committee, would allow buyers to negotiate with the broker for a percentage of the commission to be rebated back in the form of a check or a credit, likely to be used to cover closing costs. Assemblyman Patrick Diegnan, a Democrat in Middlesex County, said he introduced the bill to stimulate real estate purchases and aid buyers with closing costs.

"I practice law and for years I've seen circumstances [with] buyers who can buy a house but not cover $1,000 in closing costs," he said. "In a housing market we have now, anything we can do to encourage people to invest [in] real estate is good."

Diegnan said he hoped the ability to receive a rebate to cover purchasing costs, such as the closing, would bring more buyers into the market by allowing them to spend less money on a home purchase. He said real estate agents in his district have expressed interest in such a bill.

The New Jersey Association of Realtors opposed the original bill, which would have allowed rebates for sellers as well.

Jarrod Grasso, the association's executive vice president, said the group worked with the Assembly committee and Diegnan to draft amendments to remove rebates for sellers along with making sure information clearly states that the rebates would be taxable. Grasso said the association did not want sellers to be included because they can already negotiate the amount of a commission with a broker when signing a contract.

Grasso said the association is not actively supporting or opposing the amended bill as it works through the legislative process, but noted it would bring New Jersey in line with other states that offer rebates. Diegnan said the bill will likely go before the full Assembly in February and will be heard by the state Senate in the spring. He hopes a final bill will be sent to Gov. Jon Corzine by the end of June.

Real estate salespeople have mixed opinions on the rebates.

Lauro Arantes, a salesperson with Weichert Realtors in Jersey City, said he believes that the rebates would help bring more buyers into the market.

"It would be one more way to attract buyers and provide a service," he said.

William Decker, an agent with ERA Meeker Realty in Cranford, said he is opposed to the bill, saying that it would cause conflicts during the sales process.

"I don't like it," Decker said. "It seems conflicting that you're getting a buyer and showing them a property and getting a commission and then you're giving part of it back."


Comments

Anonymous

IDIOTS!!!! Don't they get it!! Don't they understand that the reason we're in this mess is because we passed laws that helped people who couldn't afford house to buy homes. Why would we ever pass laws like that again. IF YOU DON'T HAVE $1,000 FOR CLOSING COSTS THEN YOU CAN'T AFFORD THE HOME!!!

Comment #1 Posted By: Anonymous 01/23/09

UrbanDigs

"IF YOU DON'T HAVE $1,000 FOR CLOSING COSTS THEN YOU CAN'T AFFORD THE HOME!!!" so true!

Comment #2 Posted By: UrbanDigs 01/23/09

Anonymous

Duh!!!!! Why are these people being allowed to buy a home!!! What nonsense!

Comment #3 Posted By: Anonymous 01/23/09

Anonymous

Most brokers work too hard---especially in Manhattan with board packages---to willingly give up part of their paltry commissions. And yes, after commission splits, expenses, and long hours, a lot of commissions are paltry.

Comment #4 Posted By: Anonymous 01/23/09

Anonymous

"Rebates" to home buyers, and home sellers of real estate have been offered in many states (including NY) for some time. The DOJ has instigated, for consumers, the opportunity to engage in rebates (saving them money) in most states. Real estate agents, be ready to give it up. Hey, generic brands aren't so bad...

Comment #5 Posted By: Anonymous 01/23/09

Anonymous

Why not just have the Seller pay a certain percentage of the the closing costs directly to prevent the Buyer from having to pay taxes on any REBATE (income)?

Comment #6 Posted By: Anonymous 01/24/09

BL

Unfortunately, all but one of the above comments are wrong, misguided or shortsighted. In all but 10 states (AL, AK, KS, LA, MO, MS, NJ, OK, OR, and TN), commission rebates are allowed and utilized. Cash/credit back from rebates are NOT considered taxable income.

Comment #7 Posted By: BL 03/05/09

BL

On my last point above, in MA commission rebates are not taxable income. It appears that part of the legislation in NJ is attempting to consider it taxable.

Comment #8 Posted By: BL 03/05/09

Leave a Comment

(optional)
(optional)

The Real Deal reserves the right to delete any comment it finds to be rude, obscene, racist, sexist, bigoted, irrelevant or repetitive, as well as inappropriate comments about anyone's personal appearance. The Real Deal does not endorse any comments posted on its Web site nor does it verify the veracity of comments or the identity of posters.