Related faces opposition to 92nd Street tower

TRD New York /
Jun.June 18, 2009 04:01 PM

A showing of over 100 Upper East Side residents yesterday and speeches made by politicians were a testament to the enormous community opposition the Related Companies faces over its residential tower proposal at 205 East 92nd Street.

Yesterday’s meeting resulted in Community Board 8’s vote to reject the developer’s application for a 421-a tax abatement, which would give it a tax break on the project’s market-rate condominium component, in return for inclusion of affordable rental units.

Residents hope Related will abandon its plans if it cannot get the tax exemption.

But when one resident asked Jesse Masyr, a land use attorney representing Related, at the meeting whether or not the building would be economically viable without the 421-a abatement, Masyr responded that it still would be.

Residents are also fighting to make Related, which aims to get rid of public space to make way for its new building, provide some kind of alternate space. They argued that the area’s families have long relied on the open space, called Ruppert Playground, for recreation.

Related purchased the parcel from the city in 1983, and under the city’s 1968 Ruppert Urban Renewal Project Plan, were required to maintain it as open space, available to the public, for a period of 25 years. This time commitment ended last June, and the developer has filed preliminary plans for a 40-story building in the park’s footprint.

The developer filed for the abatement in the past month, racing for approval ahead of a July 1 deadline, after which the abatements will be subject to a new, more restrictive set of rules.  

“We are seeking to file under the existing building code, and not have to contort ourselves to the new building code, which [Related, and] most developers still don’t understand,” Masyr said.

Borough President Scott Stringer spoke confidently to the crowd, saying, “I think there’s some negotiating room here.”

He pointed to Masyr’s statement that the project does not yet have an official timeline for construction.  

“The project is not slated for any kind of action today,” he said. “I want you to know that we, and the people at Related, are ready to pull up our sleeves and work for a solution.”

The project is expected to include 49 affordable rental units for families making 80 percent of the neighborhood’s area median income, 127 market-rate rental apartments and 66 market-rate condos, as well as amenities for residents.

Community outrage to the project first erupted in late April, when more than 200 community members gathered at the park to protest the development.

After the meeting, City Council member Daniel Garodnick told The Real Deal that talks to reach an agreement with Related have been informal up until this point, but he believes the extent to which area residents oppose the project will hold weight in the city’s bargaining power to be compensated for the loss of open space.

He said the legal counsel at his office was currently “looking at every legal, legislative policy hook we can to try to deal with this situation before it gets started.”

Related Articles

Related's Jamar Adams and Steve Ross with 14-06 Gateway Boulevard (Credit: Getty Images and Google Maps)

Related is the latest developer to target the Rockaways

Related Chairman Stephen Ross (Credit: Getty Images, Wikipedia)

Related drops 700-foot-long “wall” from Hudson Yards plan

Shaun Osher, CORE CEO (Credit: Getty Images and iStock)

CORE becomes latest NY resi brokerage to expand into South Florida

Related Companies chairman Stephen Ross and Hudson Yards (Credit: Getty Images)

Next phase of Hudson Yards could include 700-foot-long wall

15 Hudson Yards (Credit: StreetEasy)

Hudson Yards pad resells for 22% premium

From left: 200 East 66th Street; Extell’s 157 West 57th Street; and 15 Hudson Yards (Credit: Street Easy)

Four home sales that caught our eye — and cost an arm and a leg

Related chairman Stephen Ross and a rendering of Western Yard (Credit: Getty Images and Hudson Yards)

Related no longer giving timetable for finishing Hudson Yards

Related chairman Stephen Ross with 30 Hudson Yards, 1633 Broadway and 55 Hudson Yards (Credit: Getty Images, Paramount, Wikipedia)

Here were NYC’s largest real estate finance deals of 2019