Second Avenue Subway hit with lawsuit

Co-op says enormous ventilation structures violate original plan

New York /
Jan.January 26, 2010 05:15 PM
 

Residents of an Upper East Side co-op filed a lawsuit last week against the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, alleging that the agency unlawfully modified the design of its massive structures that would ventilate the Second Avenue Subway (see the complaint below).

Eight permanent utility structures are planned along a 34-block stretch of Second Avenue as part of the first phase of the under-construction subway. Under the most current design, some would be as large as mid-sized apartment buildings, up to 10 stories tall. The facades would be a utilitarian mix of translucent white glass, steel louvers and ceramic tile.

The co-op tower filing the lawsuit, 233 East 69th Street, would neighbor the largest planned structure, slated to cover the entire footprint of two lots currently occupied by five-story brick apartment buildings built around the turn of last century. Once the structure is built, eight co-ops would have their easterly facing windows entirely bricked up.

When the MTA presented its renderings of the utility structures at a community board meeting last November, it was difficult to restore order, said Mark Legere, a resident of the 69th Street co-op. “There was just a complete, like a cacophony, of ‘Oh my God, not that!’ sounds.”

The lawsuit hinges on the subway’s Final Environmental Impact Statement approved in 2004, which stated that the structures “would typically be approximately the same size as a typical row house — 25 feet wide, 75 feet deep, and four- to five-stories high, although some may be wider.”

Referring to a four-story brick building with faux windows, the document says the structures “could be designed to appear like a neighborhood row house in height, scale, materials and colors.”

The MTA did not comment by press time, but spokesperson Kevin Ortiz recently told The Real Deal that the structures are needed to house the subway’s state-of-the-art ventilation and smoke evacuation systems, utilities, and emergency exits. Sidewalk grates now violate the city’s building code.

Ortiz had said the brick rendering was just an example, noting, “at that point we didn’t even have a conceptual design,” and added that the size of the current design is consistent with what a private developer could build under zoning laws.

The residents are telling the MTA to redesign the utility structures so they mimic typical row houses, as outlined in the original plan.

“Otherwise, if the MTA insists on moving forward with this design change, then it must conduct an additional public environmental review, including a full analysis of the facility’s impacts on the buildings at 233 East 69th Street, and an evaluation of suitable mitigation measures or alternatives to avoid or minimize the facility’s impacts to the greatest extent practicable,” said the residents’ attorney, Michael D. Zarin of Zarin & Steinmetz.

Zarin said the supplemental environmental review process “can take anywhere between six months to a year, if done correctly.”

The delay-plagued subway has been planned since 1929, but had been stopped by two financial crashes and one war over the decades. This most recent attempt at constructing the subway originally pegged the completion date as 2012, but The Real Deal reported in July that straphangers might have to wait until 2017.

“We would think that would be their interest [to revert to the original design]. They certainly won’t want to go through a lengthy and protracted environmental review process,” Zarin said.

The co-op residents attempted to negotiate with the MTA out-of-court, but received a letter from the agency Jan. 13 declining to modify its plans for the utility structure.
Second Ave Subway 69th St Complaint


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
New York Governor Kathy Hochul touring construction in the subway (Getty)
Hochul promises Second Avenue Subway work to advance in 2022
Hochul promises Second Avenue Subway work to advance in 2022
Photo Illustration of Douglas Durst, chairman of the Durst Organization (Getty)
Durst accuses MTA of stalling East Harlem development
Durst accuses MTA of stalling East Harlem development
Sen. Charles Schumer, President Joe Biden and Mayor-elect Eric Adams with the BQE (Getty, iStock)
Goodbye BQE? How infrastructure bill boosts real estate
Goodbye BQE? How infrastructure bill boosts real estate
A photo illustration of Gov. Andrew Cuomo and Mayor Bill de Blasio (Getty)
Congress came through. Why is real estate not satisfied?
Congress came through. Why is real estate not satisfied?
Dalton Gomez and Ariana Grande (Compass, Getty, Instagram/ArianaGrande)
Ariana Grande and Compass’ Dalton Gomez engaged
Ariana Grande and Compass’ Dalton Gomez engaged
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (Getty)
Stimulus to extend eviction moratorium, provide $25B in rent relief
Stimulus to extend eviction moratorium, provide $25B in rent relief
(Getty)
MTA proposes percentage-based rent payments for Grand Central retailers
MTA proposes percentage-based rent payments for Grand Central retailers
TRD's Erik Engquist and MTA Chief Development Officer Janno Lieber 
MTA development chief: Capital budget will be “cannibalized” without federal aid
MTA development chief: Capital budget will be “cannibalized” without federal aid
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...