Park51 developer fires back at 9/11 firefighter

TRD New York /
Jan.January 15, 2011 07:56 PM

Park51 developer Soho Properties yesterday filed a motion to dismiss a lawsuit to block the proposed Islamic mosque and community center, arguing that the Ground Zero firefighter challenging the project lacks standing to make the complaint and that he failed to name the correct owner of the site of the proposed mosque.

Retired New York City firefighter Timothy Brown filed suit in New York State Supreme Court in October challenging a Landmarks Preservation Commission ruling in August 2010 that denied landmark status for the site, at at 45-47 Park Place, therefore allowing the proposed Islamic center to proceed.

Lawyers for Soho Properties, led by chairman Sharif El-Gamal, argued that Brown lacks any legal standing to sue, as he failed to demonstrate how he personally would be injured by the LPC ruling. Brown, one of the first firefighters to respond to the Sept. 11 attacks, claimed to be part of a preservationist group that had an interest in the historical significance of the building and the surrounding area near the World Trade Center site.

In addition, lawyers for the developer argued that Brown named the developer, Soho Properties, but failed to name the actual owner of the building, 45 Park Place Partners, which must be a named party in such a lawsuit. Lawyers said the statute of limitations for Brown to name the owner ran out Dec. 3, and therefore the suit must be thrown out.

“They didn’t sue the proper party,” said attorney Adam Leitman Bailey, who represents Soho Properties. “The guy who is suing doesn’t have proper standing to sue. He’s not injured; he has to be injured [by the LPC ruling] to sue.” El-Gamal was not immediately available for comment.

Lawyers for the firefighter countered that the firefighter has a legitimate interest in the fate of the project, and that if the proper defendant was not named in the suit, that can be amended in a new filing.

“He has an interest in preserving the historical integrity of the building that’s so close to where he responded,” said attorney Jack Lester, one of two lawyers representing Brown. “He has an interest apart from the general public, that’s why he’s named as a plaintiff.”

A court hearing is scheduled for Jan.19.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
The Strand Bookstore and store owner Nancy Bass Wyden (Credit: Getty Images)

Over owner’s protests, city landmarks Strand bookstore

Revamped design for 550 Madison receives Landmarks’ approval

Revamped design for 550 Madison receives Landmarks’ approval

The Top 10 preservation fights of 2018

The Top 10 preservation fights of 2018

Abercrombie and Fitch CEO Fran Horowitz and an aerial view of 600 Broadway, blocked by 606 Broadway (Credit: Getty Images, Google Maps)

The curious case of 600 Broadway

From left: Savanna’s founding partners, Christopher Schlank and Nicholas Bienstock, Tokyo Trust Capital CEO Minoru Machida and 434 BroadwayFrom left: Savanna’s founding partners, Christopher Schlank and Nicholas Bienstock, Tokyo Trust Capital CEO Minoru Machida and 434 Broadway

Savanna sells Soho office building for $103M to Tokyo-based firm

591-593 Broadway (Credit: Google Maps)  

Another pricey retail building in Soho is up for sale

136 Grand Street, #3WR

Buyer nabs $8.8M condo with mirrored room, stripper pole

Blades founder Jeff Kabat and the store at 659 Broadway (Credit: LinkedIn and Google Maps)

Skate gear retailer Blades to close its last store

arrow_forward_ios
Loading...