Stuy Town tenants cleared to pursue $215M in rent overcharges

Nov.November 03, 2011 05:52 PM

Stuyvesand Town and City Council member Daniel Garodnick
The New York state appeals court ruled today that tenants in the
blockbuster lawsuit at Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village
will be able to pursue millions in rent overcharges, tossing a move to dismiss the case by MetLife, the original landlord of the Manhattan complex (note: correction appended).

In 2007, Stuy Town residents, led by tenant Amy Roberts, filed
a class action suit against Tishman and the previous landlord,
Metropolitan Life, alleging they illegally deregulated apartments
while receiving J-51 tax benefits, which are designed to help
landlords renovate apartment buildings in return for keeping rents

The decision means that thousands of current and former tenants
will be able to pursue more than $215 million in excess rent that
was paid to previous landlord Tishman Speyer or MetLife, which
had sold the complex to Tishman.

“The class members who were overcharged are now entitled to be
reimbursed,” said Wolf Haldenstein attorney Alex Schmidt, who
represented the tenants in the Stuy Town lawsuit.

Tenants have been negotiating with the former landlords on a
settlement for more than five months, Schmidt said. City Council
member Daniel Garodnick, a lifelong tenant at the complex and
an advocate for tenants, said the ruling should help bring a final
resolution to the case.

“The harm done to Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village
residents extends years in the past, and today’s victory will help
ensure that they can be made whole for their landlord’s flouting of
the law,” Garodnick said in a statement.

Tishman Speyer and BlackRock acquired the 11,000-unit complex
in 2006 for a record $5.6 billion, and later defaulted when the
market crashed and the value of the complex fell underwater. The
property was later taken over by CW Capital
, the special servicer
that managed the defaulted loans.

The collapse of the deal was considered one of the biggest
debacles of the real estate boom, and this decision will add further
pain to landlords across the city.

The decision affirms a landmark ruling in August where Bernard
and Cora Gersten were awarded retroactive rent at a small
Greenwich Village apartment at 56 Seventh Avenue.

“It was always clear to me that retroactivity was a no brainer,” said
attorney William Gribben, who represented tenants in the Gersten
case. “This was something that the landlord world thought might
come to their rescue and relieve all their pain.”

The original ruling was widely criticized by the real estate industry, as
landlords across New York feared that tenants would file suit to
get refunds in buildings that were illegally deregulated.

A spokesperson for Tishman Speyer declined comment and a
spokesperson for MetLife was not immediately available for

Related Articles

Blackstone CEO Steven Schwartzman and Stuyvesant Town (Credit: Getty Images)

After authorities vowed review of Stuy Town deal, Blackstone changes course on vacancies

The Wheeler at 181 Livingston Street with Tishman Speyer's Rob Speyer (Credit: The Wheeler, Getty Images)

For-profit Whittle School inks lease for Tishman Speyer’s The Wheeler

The Spiral and Debevoise presiding partner Michael W. Blair (Credit: Tishman Speyer)

Debevoise signs big lease at Tishman Speyer’s Spiral

Related chairman Stephen Ross with 30 Hudson Yards, 1633 Broadway and 55 Hudson Yards (Credit: Getty Images, Paramount, Wikipedia)

Here were NYC’s largest real estate finance deals of 2019

50 Rockefeller Plaza and Katten's Chris DiAngelo (Credit: Google and Katten)

Katten law firm moving to Rockefeller Center

From left: Jonathan Gray and Steve Schwarzman with Stuyvesant Town

Behind Blackstone’s “capital strike”

Clockwise from the top left: Jackson Park at 28-40 Jackson Avenue, 240 Willoughby Street in Fort Greene, 664 Pacific Street in Brooklyn, and 247 Metropolitan Avenue in Williamsburg (Credit: StreetEasy, Google Maps, Pacific Park Brooklyn, The Pod Hotel)

These were the top 10 outer-borough loans last month

October Issue is Live

The Real Deal‘s October issue is now available to subscribers!