Wall Street opposes mortgage restructuring plan championed by Shiller

TRD NEW YORK /
Jun.June 28, 2012 01:30 PM

Wall Street’s largest lobbying firm, the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association, is crying foul at calls for the use of eminent domain laws to seize and restructure underwater mortgages, Bloomberg News reported. The firm is concerned that forcing private entities to sell bonds at a fair price will lead to a slippery slope of further government buyouts.

“We have very serious concerns and strong objection to the concept of using eminent domain to seize a mortgage for the purpose of restructuring it, no matter how meritorious the goal might be,” Ken Bentsen, SIFMA executive vice president for public policy and advocacy said. “We think it raises the serious constitutional issues of a government entity overstepping its bounds.”

The plan is being considered by several California municipalities where the housing bust has left a large number of homeowners owing more than their properties’ values.

The concept of applying eminent domain to the housing crisis was originally proposed by the San Francisco-based investment firm Mortgage Resolution Partners and was championed last week by Robert Shiller, Yale economics professor and co-creator of the S&P/Case-Shiller Index, in a New York Times op-ed. Shiller argues that government seizure of mortgages is the only way to ensure principal reductions in an environment where so many people with financial interest in mortgages are spread throughout the country and unable to take collective action.

Despite Wall Street’s objections independent legal experts seem to agree that the use of eminent domain to serve a valid public purpose has been tested by the courts and meets constitutional muster. [Bloomberg]


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
(Credit: iStock)

Thousands of CRE borrowers call on banks for debt relief

Banks, funds, mortgage REITs, and agencies like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have all begun adjusting their lending approach in face of the economic downturn (Credit: iStock)

These are the sectors where real estate lending is still happening: report

Angel Oak Cos. CEO Michael Fierman and Flagstar Bancorp Inc. CEO Alessandro DiNello (Credit: Angel Oak, Flagstar, iStock)

Mortgage market dries up for unconventional home loans

As banks demand more collateral and developers stop making mortgage payments, analysts expect a world of pain to befall debt funds, mortgage REITs (Credit: iStock)

Mortgage REITs, debt funds face catch-22 between banks, developers

From left: Ace Watanasuparp, SVP National Director of Strategic Sales, Citizens Bank; Alan Rosenbaum, CEO/Founder, GuardHill Financial Corp; Mark Favaloro, President, New York Association of Mortgage Brokers

Home lending in the time of corona: “Underwriting is really difficult right now”

Ginnie Mae principal executive vice president Seth Appleton (Credit: Wikipedia Commons; MHS)

Ginnie Mae to use natural disaster program to help struggling mortgage servicers

(Credit: iStock)

“Kicking the can down the road”: Real estate industry says $2T relief plan doesn’t do enough

Clockwise from top left: California Gov. Gavin Newsom, Illinois Gov. J. B. Pritzker, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo and Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (Credit, in order: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images, Joshua Lott/Getty Images, Bennett Raglin/Getty Images, Joe Raedle/Getty Images) 

Real estate orgs call for appraisals to be deemed essential

arrow_forward_ios
Loading...