Wall Street opposes mortgage restructuring plan championed by Shiller

New York /
Jun.June 28, 2012 01:30 PM

Wall Street’s largest lobbying firm, the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association, is crying foul at calls for the use of eminent domain laws to seize and restructure underwater mortgages, Bloomberg News reported. The firm is concerned that forcing private entities to sell bonds at a fair price will lead to a slippery slope of further government buyouts.

“We have very serious concerns and strong objection to the concept of using eminent domain to seize a mortgage for the purpose of restructuring it, no matter how meritorious the goal might be,” Ken Bentsen, SIFMA executive vice president for public policy and advocacy said. “We think it raises the serious constitutional issues of a government entity overstepping its bounds.”

The plan is being considered by several California municipalities where the housing bust has left a large number of homeowners owing more than their properties’ values.

The concept of applying eminent domain to the housing crisis was originally proposed by the San Francisco-based investment firm Mortgage Resolution Partners and was championed last week by Robert Shiller, Yale economics professor and co-creator of the S&P/Case-Shiller Index, in a New York Times op-ed. Shiller argues that government seizure of mortgages is the only way to ensure principal reductions in an environment where so many people with financial interest in mortgages are spread throughout the country and unable to take collective action.

Despite Wall Street’s objections independent legal experts seem to agree that the use of eminent domain to serve a valid public purpose has been tested by the courts and meets constitutional muster. [Bloomberg]


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
 An industry report says that mortgage lenders and investors are ill-prepared for the growing challenge of climate risk. (iStock)
Mortgage market stakeholders are unprepared for growing climate change threats
Mortgage market stakeholders are unprepared for growing climate change threats
Mortgage availability improves just as rates set to rise
Mortgage availability improves just as rates set to rise
Mortgage availability improves just as rates set to rise
Pittsburgh is the place to be for affordable mortgage payments. San Jose and San Francisco? Not so much. (iStock)
Ten most/least expensive cities to buy a median-priced home
Ten most/least expensive cities to buy a median-priced home
Real estate stocks climbed higher in August despite the end of a national eviction moratorium and uncertainty over how the delta variant would affect retail spending and a return to the office. (iStock)
Real estate stocks dodge obstacles, charge forward in August
Real estate stocks dodge obstacles, charge forward in August
A statistical analysis found that lenders were 80 percent more likely to reject Black applicants for mortgages in 2019. (iStock)
Secret bias in mortgage algorithms hurts borrowers of color
Secret bias in mortgage algorithms hurts borrowers of color
From left: JPMorganChase CEO Jamie Dimon, Goldman Sachs CEO David Solomon and Morgan Stanley CEO James Gorman (Getty)
Demand for private-label mortgages on the rise
Demand for private-label mortgages on the rise
Rocket Companies originates record home purchase mortgages despite industry headwinds
Rocket Companies originates record home purchase mortgages despite industry headwinds
Rocket Companies originates record home purchase mortgages despite industry headwinds
Divvy Homes CEO Adena Hefets (Twitter)
Divvy Homes hits $2B valuation on new fundraising round
Divvy Homes hits $2B valuation on new fundraising round
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...