Washington Heights renter prevails in “game changer” case

New York /
Aug.August 14, 2013 02:00 PM

Law firm Kucker & Bruh will have to cough up $22,000 to an 82-year-old Washington Heights tenant, who claimed the firm launched a bogus eviction case against him on behalf of a landlord client — a case said to be the first of its kind.

Rafael Lee, a resident of 810 West 183rd Street, claimed the firm went after him for $1,125 in unpaid back rent.

This was allegedly despite his landlord, Woodfin Properties, collecting a monthly senior citizen rent subsidy that offset his rental costs.

He received a pretrial settlement, plus legal fees, last week.

“I believe this is the first time that a landlord law firm has been sued for this kind of violation,” said Lee’s attorney, James Fishman, referring to federal debt collection laws. “I would call it a game changer in housing court.”

Lawyers from the firm did not respond to requests for comment. Officials from the landlord or managing agent were not immediately available for comment.

Lee has been a tenant at the five-story walkup apartment complex since 1965, according to court documents. His legal rent in March 2012 was about $790.30, but his rent has been fixed at $400.72 per month since 1995, under the Senior Citizen Rent Increase Exemption, documents show.

The dispute started when Woodfin sued Lee to collect $1,125, which included $790 for March 2012, plus eight months of $38 fuel payments and a $30 balance from February. The delinquent notice showed that a $400.72 payment had been made, but was not credited against the balance.

However, Lee’s lawyers submitted evidence that the subsidy should have been properly credited, and the property’s managing agent, Mall Properties, withdrew the eviction case in May 2012. Lee was awarded legal fees but then sued Kucker & Bruh in federal court, claiming they had violated federal debt collection laws.

Kucker & Bruh argued that they made an excusable mistake. But in her ruling, Judge Lorna Schofield said that bill collectors are under strict liability based on federal debt collection law and that the firm did not have adequate procedures to prevent the mistake.

“There is no dispute that the defendants mischaracterized the character, amount and legal status of Mr. Lee’s debt,” Judge Schofield wrote. “Because defendants lacked procedures reasonably adopted to avoid the error, the bona fide error defense of [the statute] does not apply.”

Fishman, a leading tenant lawyer, said that landlords often target seniors or tenants on Section 8 subsidies with frivolous lawsuits. The idea is to force them out of their apartments, deregulate the units, and bring in tenants who can pay higher rent.

“It’s a well known landlord scheme that if you sue somebody repeatedly for non-payment that they’re either going to give up and move out or they’re going to default and get evicted,” he told The Real Deal.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Matt Lauer exposes Hamptons estate to the market
Matt Lauer exposes Hamptons estate to the market
Matt Lauer exposes Hamptons estate to the market
 Fredrik Eklund and the property (Getty, Steve Frankel)
Fredrik Eklund lists Bel Air mansion for rent as family moves to “forever home”
Fredrik Eklund lists Bel Air mansion for rent as family moves to “forever home”
Gordon Ramsey and his Lucky Cat restaurant (Lucky Cat)
Gordon Ramsay to open first South Florida restaurant in Miami Beach
Gordon Ramsay to open first South Florida restaurant in Miami Beach
The Watermark, a senior-living facility in Brooklyn Heights (Watermark)
High-end assisted living facilities popping up around the country
High-end assisted living facilities popping up around the country
The mansion used as a setting in the film "House of Gucci." (Airbnb)
Get your Gucci on: Mansion featured in Lady Gaga movie available on Airbnb
Get your Gucci on: Mansion featured in Lady Gaga movie available on Airbnb
Austin, Texas saw pricing of 5 to 9 percent above asking in the first six months of the year. (iStock)
In 10 years, homes in Austin, Texas go from bargain-basement to sky-high
In 10 years, homes in Austin, Texas go from bargain-basement to sky-high
Making money moves: Cardi B buying up real estate
Making money moves: Cardi B buying up real estate
Making money moves: Cardi B buying up real estate
New York Governor Kathy Hochul touring construction in the subway (Getty)
Hochul promises Second Avenue Subway work to advance in 2022
Hochul promises Second Avenue Subway work to advance in 2022
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...