Airbnb host scores legal victory with “roommate defense”

TRD New York /
Oct.October 03, 2013 03:25 PM

A recent Airbnb host fined $2,400 scored a favorable decision from the New York City Environmental Control Board after arguing his roommate was present during the tourists’ stay.

The short-term rental site, while not named in the case, joined host Nigel Warren on appeal and paid for his defense. Airbnb touted the ruling as a victory for “the sharing community” in New York, but legal experts say much gray area remains.

“This doesn’t represent most of the rentals that Airbnb or any of the other occupancy facilitators engage in,” said Sherwin Belkin of Belkin Burden Wenig & Goldman.

The typical situation Belkin and other lawyers see, as they told Law360, is one in which a primary occupant takes out an Airbnb ad offering an entire apartment for a short-term rental, during which he or she is not present.

Such cases are unaffected by the decision.

The challenge, as The Real Deal previously reported, is that the onus for proving whether tenants are present during such a rental falls on the condominium and co-op boards suing them. Even the “roommate defense” falls on somewhat shaky ground, as the question of a paid guest violates a slew of other laws and regulations. [Law360]Julie Strickland

Related Articles

From left: Mayor Bill de Blasio, 54 West 39th Street, 62 Grand Street, and 208 West 30th Street (Credit: Google Maps)

The Airbnb crackdown continues: City targets three more buildings

Mayor Bill de Blasio and Stanley “Skip” Karol, an Airbnb host (Credit: Getty Images and Youtube)

Airbnb host narrowly clears hurdle in First Amendment claim against city

A West Village Airbnb listing (Credit: Airbnb)

Airbnb Luxe launched without listings in one of their biggest potential markets — why?

Rendering of the Staybridge Suites at 38-59 11th Street

Long Island City hotel project moves forward with construction loan

Airbnb lost by a landslide in Jersey City. What went wrong?

Airbnb lost by a landslide in Jersey City. What went wrong?

Results are in from Jersey City Airbnb referendum

Airbnb deflated as Jersey City voters tighten rental rules

Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky and Jersey City Mayor Steve Fulop (Credit: Twitter, iStock, Airbnb)

Stakes are high as Jersey City residents vote on Airbnb

Heritage Equity Partners’ Toby Moskovits, Benefit Street Partners real estate managing director Micah Goodman, and the Williamsburg Hotel at 96 Wythe Avenue (Credit: Google Maps)

Toby Moskovits’ Williamsburg Hotel is headed for receivership following $68M loan default