Court rules in favor of Empire State Building buyout provision

Shareholders were not unfairly pressured into IPO, court says

TRD New York /
Feb.February 25, 2014 04:39 PM

Malkin Holdings’ buyout provision for shareholders who voted against taking the Empire State Building public has been ruled legal in State Appellate Court.

The company, headed by Anthony Malkin, said it would exercise a clause permitting the company to buy out dissenting voters for $100 per share, a tiny portion of the shares’ estimated value of more than $300,000 each. Shareholders against the IPO filed suit, arguing that the move strong-armed them into going along with the plan, forcing them to vote in favor or risk being bought out for next to nothing.

But because the Empire State Building shareholders were not part of a limited liability company, the court found that they were not unfairly pressured, Crain’s reported.

“The motion court promptly denied appellants’ application for a declaration that the buyout provisions violate the Limited Liability Company Law since appelants are not ‘members’ in the limited liability company who are entitled to the fair value appraisal protections,” the judgement said. [Crain’s]Julie Strickland

Related Articles


Trump’s tax returns, Amazon gets into proptech: Daily digest

Empire State Realty Trust's David A. Karp

Empire State Realty Trust’s CFO David Karp is stepping down

Time Equities CEO Francis Greenburger and Empire State Realty Trust CEO Anthony Malkin (Credit: Getty Images and iStock)

Going green has some city landlords seeing red

Infrastructure firm expands to more than 100K sf at Empire State Building

Can ESRT finally fix its retail problem?

This real estate player paid $16K for Trump’s doodle of the Empire State Building

Empire State Building owner to spend up to $150M on new observatory entrance

Anthony Malkin concerned over “PR bruise” from Trump travel ban