Harlem residents fight developer’s $4.25M suit

New York /
Apr.April 12, 2014 09:00 AM

Residents of a city-subsidized Harlem co-op are pushing back after being hit with a $4.25 million lawsuit by the developer for complaining about inferior construction and repairs.

Madison Park Development Associates, led by BFC Partners managing principal Donald Capoccia, filed a defamation and interference lawsuit against three 1831 Madison Ave. residents over their complaints to politicians about shoddy construction and repairs at the nine-story building.

Madison Park, which used city financing to build the co-op for middle-income New Yorkers at E. 119th St., claims that Judith Febbraro, Gerald Magpily and Ellen Ackrish “disseminated false and defamatory information” in a 2012 letter to politicians and the Department of Housing Preservation and Development. The suit also says the three weren’t authorized to write on behalf of the whole co-op.

The homeowners claim, however, that their letter had dozens of residents’ signatures and was an innocent plea for assistance. They say the building has had leaks since it was built in 2002.

“I have no problem with people raising fact-based concerns, but when they make things up, we have no choice but to defend our record,” said Capoccia, who argues that the building is now in good shape. The suit seeks a $1.25 million judgment and $1 million in damages from each of the defendants.

The homeowners say the lawsuit is a bullying tactic by Capoccia, who is president of the New York State Association for Affordable Housing.

“Tenants should not have to fear being sued for millions of dollars about problems with their housing conditions,” said Yetta Kurland, the lawyer for the homeowners. “New York’s civil rights law makes it illegal to sue a private citizen who speaks out on public issues.” [NYDN] —TRD


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Attorney General Letitia James, Tax Equity Now’s Policy Director Martha Stark and Mayor-Elect Eric Adams (Getty)
Do-or-die: Group files final appeal for property tax reform
Do-or-die: Group files final appeal for property tax reform
(Getty)
Weekly home listings hit record low
Weekly home listings hit record low
East Village landlord collected rent from deceased CEO’s account, lawsuit says
East Village landlord collected rent from deceased CEO’s account, lawsuit says
East Village landlord collected rent from deceased CEO’s account, lawsuit says
City law protecting commercial tenants upheld on appeal
City law protecting commercial tenants upheld on appeal
City law protecting commercial tenants upheld on appeal
The year-over-year rise in home prices was just below the 19.8 percent annual rise in August. (iStock)
Home prices up 20%, but buyers, take heart
Home prices up 20%, but buyers, take heart
Former Newmark brokers Christopher Cowan, Shane Ozment, and Terrance Hunt (CoStar)
Ex-Newmark brokers appeal 1-year ban after judge upholds noncompete
Ex-Newmark brokers appeal 1-year ban after judge upholds noncompete
Children’s Magical Garden at at 157 Norfolk Street (Google Maps, Facebook)
Children’s Magical Garden claps back against developer who claimed defamation
Children’s Magical Garden claps back against developer who claimed defamation
Illustration of Zillow CEO Richard Barton (Getty, iStock/Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
Zestimate: These two Zillow iBuying lawsuits won’t be the last
Zestimate: These two Zillow iBuying lawsuits won’t be the last
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...