Jackson Group defeats bid to enforce sale of NoMad buildings

Rabsky Group agrees to withdraw suit over canceled deal for 273 and 275 Fifth Avenue

New York /
May.May 15, 2014 12:06 PM

The retail-focused investment firm the Jackson Group, along with another local owner, used an unusual legal strategy last month to successfully fight off an effort by development company the Rabsky Group to enforce a $33 million sale of two adjacent NoMad buildings.

The Jackson Group, led by brothers Ike, Elliott and Gabriel Chehebar, and Rinel Realty asked a judge to compel the Williamsburg-based Rabsky Group to put up a $3.2 million bond while lawsuits filed in New York State Supreme Court in March over the canceled sales of 273 and 275 Fifth Avenue were pending, court records show. Complex cases of this nature can last for months or even years, meaning that money could be tied up and not available for investment or development.

But just four days after the motion was filed, all three parties agreed to a stipulation signed April 14 withdrawing the Rabsky lawsuit, a review of court documents revealed.

An attorney representing the Rabsky Group did not respond to a request for comment. Peter Sherwin, a partner with the firm Proskauer Rose, who represented the Jackson Group and Rinel Realty, declined to comment.

The Rabsky Group, led by Simon Dushinsky, is an extremely active developer, with projects set for the East Village, Crown Heights and Long Island City, among other sites.

The NoMad properties are located in one of Manhattan’s many submarkets that have undergone significant development in recent years, and are in line for more. Kushner Real Estate Group has plans to develop a 40-story tower on the block, at 281 Fifth Avenue in partnership with Ironstate Development.

The four-story 273 Fifth Avenue has 8,060 square feet and includes a total of 26,000 square feet of development rights, while the neighboring five-story 275 Fifth Avenue has 9,269 square feet and includes 23,000 square feet of development rights, data from PropertyShark shows.

Rabsky filed the original lawsuit on March 24, along with notices of pendency against both buildings, which make it virtually impossible to sell or lease the buildings. Rabsky Group, led by Simon Dushinsky, claimed in court papers that it had signed an agreement to purchase 275 Fifth Avenue from the Jackson Group for $14.139 million and to Purchase 273 Fifth Avenue from Rinel Realty for $18.861 million.

Both sellers decided not to go forward with the sale, and on March 20 notified Rabsky that the transactions were canceled. Rabsky responded with the lawsuit.

To defeat the lawsuit and the notices of pendency, Jackson Group and Rinel requested that the case simply be dismissed, alleging that the contracts were void an unenforceable. But in an unusual move, the pair also asked the judge to require Rabksy to post the bond to cover monthly costs as well as $2.5 million in one-time capital costs for 273 Fifth Avenue.

The stipulation of discontinuance signed by all parties does not explain the cause for the withdrawal. It was filed on April 14, however, leading some insiders to speculate it was related to the demand for the bond.

This strategy is infrequently used, legal sources said. Darren Oved, a partner with the law firm Oved & Oved said that the specific statute (known as CPLR 6515), has been cited just 50 or so times in the past decade in published decisions.

Because the strategy requires the litigants to put up sizable bonds, it also forces a plaintiff to “put its money where its mouth is,” Oved said.

Therefore, “it is a seldom used litigation tactic, particularly in New York City where property values are high and the figures can peak into 8 or 9 figures,” he added.

The Jackson Group, active as a retail owner, signed a contract last month with partners to buy a grocery store building in Cobble Hill for $18.5 million that they plan to redevelop into a modern retail location.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Rabsky Group buying Gowanus parcel from Yoel Goldman for $95M: sources
Rabsky Group buying Gowanus parcel from Yoel Goldman for $95M: sources
Rabsky Group buying Gowanus parcel from Yoel Goldman for $95M: sources
From left: Vanbarton Group’s Gary Tischler and Richard Coles along with 3 West 29th Street (Getty, Vanbarton Group, Google Maps)
Vanbarton eyes life sciences project at former HFZ site in NoMad
Vanbarton eyes life sciences project at former HFZ site in NoMad
SpringHealth CEO April Koh, 60 Madison Avenue and Moinian Group’s Joseph Moinian (SpringHealth, VTS, Moinian)
Youngest female unicorn CEO moves startup to Moinian’s 60 Madison Avenue
Youngest female unicorn CEO moves startup to Moinian’s 60 Madison Avenue
25 West 28th Street, No Mad, Hotels
NoMad hotel market set for 25% property boost
NoMad hotel market set for 25% property boost
G4 Capital's Robyn Sorid and a rendering of 313-315 Bond Street (G4 Capital, LinkedIn/Robyn Sorid)
Rabsky Group scores $92M loan for big Gowanus project
Rabsky Group scores $92M loan for big Gowanus project
Clockwise from top left: 277 Fifth Avenue, 60 North 6th Street in Brooklyn, 127 Kent Avenue in Brooklyn and 515 West 38th Street (The LX Collection, L3 Capital, Google Maps)
Tile maker’s deal in NoMad leads mid-market sales
Tile maker’s deal in NoMad leads mid-market sales
11 East 26th Street and 15 East 26th Street (Google Maps)
Rockrose takes over NoMad office building in $145M deal
Rockrose takes over NoMad office building in $145M deal
Render of 240 Willoughby Street & Martin Nussbaum, co-founder and principal of Slate Property (Slate Property Group)
Slate lends Rabsky $72M for Fort Greene multifamily project
Slate lends Rabsky $72M for Fort Greene multifamily project
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...