Americans slow to move into new homes

Pricey broker fees, transaction costs, mortgage fees drag on household mobility, chart shows

TRD New York /
Jul.July 10, 2014 02:05 PM

The household mobility rate, or the percent of the population that moves into a new home in a year, has been in a long-term decline. This trend has been unfavorable for the housing market, which in turn has been a drag on GDP.

According to Michelle Meyer at Bank of America Merrill Lynch, the household mobility rate has been slowing since the mid-1980s.

A key driver of this trend has been the rise of homeownership in the 1990s. Homeowners are less like to move than renters. It’s much more expensive for homeowners to move because of broker fees, transaction costs, mortgage fees, insurance and so on.

From 2000 on, aging population and changes in the labor market have also been negative for household mobility.

There Are Two Reason Why Household Mobility Could Improve

In the short run, two factors could cause household mobility to pick up: the decline in homeownership rates and rising home prices.

“The homeownership rate has plunged from the peak in late 2004, and we think the risk is that it continues to slide,” writes Meyer. “Homeowners are less mobile than renters — from 2012 to 2013, 25% of renters moved compared to 5% of owners. The shift toward greater renting should boost the aggregate mobility rate.”

Negative equity, in which a borrower owes more on their mortgage than their home is worth, also reduces household mobility. “As home prices continue to rise, a growing number of homeowners will move into positive equity, allowing for greater mobility,” she writes.

Longer-Term Trends Remain Unfavorable

In the long run however, an aging population and the end of ultra-low mortgage rates will curb household mobility.

“The greatest propensity to move is when people are in their late 20s. The mobility rate steadily declines thereafter as people age,” according to Meyer.

“We should also be concerned that mortgage ‘lock-in’ will reduce mobility over the medium term. We expect rates to head higher in the coming years, increasing mortgage payments. It will be difficult for those homeowners who bought or refinanced to a fixed-rate mortgage over the past few years to give up the record low rate.”

Meyer told Business Insider in an email interview that, in the short-run, an uptick in household mobility will help boost residential investment as a share of GDP. In the longer-term, however, “residential investment may struggle to return to the historical average of GDP, suggesting lower multipliers from housing to the rest of the economy going forward.”

Related Articles

Clockwise from the top left: Jackson Park at 28-40 Jackson Avenue, 240 Willoughby Street in Fort Greene, 664 Pacific Street in Brooklyn, and 247 Metropolitan Avenue in Williamsburg (Credit: StreetEasy, Google Maps, Pacific Park Brooklyn, The Pod Hotel)

These were the top 10 outer-borough loans last month

Jackson Park at 28-40 Jackson Avenue and Tishman Speyer's Rob Speyer (Credit: StreetEasy and Tishman Speyer)

Tishman Speyer locks in $1B in financing for Jackson Park

One Bryant Park (Credit: The Durst Organization)

Bank of America leads $1.6B refi for tower named after it at One Bryant Park

MCR Development CEO Tyler Morse and a rendering of TWA Flight Center

Revamped TWA Flight Center at JFK lands $270M loan

Dream Hotel Group's Sant Singh Chatwal (left) and Charles Holzer (right) and 355 West 16th Street (Credit: Getty Images and Google Maps)

Land under Dream Downtown hotel sells
for $175M

Atlas Hospitality lands $40M loan for planned FiDi hotel tower

Despite an “overheated” market, Bank of America is ramping up its CRE exposure

HJ Kalikow lands a $365M loan for 101 Park