Urban, suburban, is it all the same?

Suburbs are starting to look incredibly diverse, raising questions about what it means to say you are from "the city"

TRD New York /
Jul.July 26, 2014 12:00 PM

 When abroad, suburbanites often use the closest major city as a proxy. “I’m from New York City,” could easily mean Long Island in a café in Madrid. But according to the Atlantic’s City Lab blog, we shouldn’t judge these suburbanites for claiming urbanite status, because the suburbs simply aren’t what they used to be.

For one, suburbs are becoming nearly as diverse as cities themselves.

“The 2008 U.S. Census update revealed that racial and ethnic minorities now make up one-third of the total suburban population in the nation’s one hundred largest metropolitan regions,” urban historians and sociologists Matthew D. Lassiter and Christopher Niedt wrote in a recent study published in The Journal of Urban History.

“[There are] residential patterns that include affluent single-family neighborhoods, high-poverty inner-ring suburbs… and exurban developments hit hard by predatory subprime lending and the ongoing foreclosure crisis. The U.S. suburban population now includes a majority of both first-generation immigrants and poor residents of metropolitan areas, and nearly half of all renters. Despite the persistence of the traditional nuclear family ideal, only about one-fourth of today’s suburban households consist of heterosexual married couples with children under the age of eighteen,” they wrote.

In fact, many city leaders are ditching the dichotomy between urban and suburban altogether. They argue that it is better to think of suburbs as a network of villages, unified by a larger metropolitan area.

Maybe they’re right, but that isn’t going to stop city snobs from calling out suburbanites next time they evoke the city as their own. At least for now. [The Atlantic] Christopher Cameron

Related Articles


Most Americans claim they live in the ‘burbs, including 18% of New Yorkers

Why Westchester homes are getting battered by “dramatic price reductions”

Long Island Cheat Sheet: Douglas Elliman ranks as top resi brokerage in LI, three Smithtown sites move toward redevelopment … & more

Cruisin’ the ‘burbs: City dwellers are looking out for a deal in these 10 secondary markets

Why increasing numbers of New Yorkers are calling it quits on city life

Multifamily investors head to the ‘burbs in search of yield

Westchester & Fairfield Cheat Sheet: Stamford rental building trades for $25M, controversial White Plains school plan gets a green light … & more

From the archives: The king of suburbia