Oddball properties create lending conundrum

Difficulty finding “comps” causes mortgage underwriters to balk at unique homes

New York /
Sep.September 05, 2014 10:55 AM

Unique homes may hold a certain appeal for homebuyers seeking a residence that is off the beaten path. But securing financing for an unusual property can prove challenging.

Such out-of-the-box dwellings often prove difficult to value, as appraisers may struggle to find a comparable home that can serve as a pricing reference point. The issue often arises with homes that are unusual for a region. “What’s normal in Beverly Hills would be unusual in Brooklyn,” Peter Grabel, managing director at Luxury Mortgage of Stamford, Conn. told the New York Times). Homes that are atypical for a neighborhood or even just unusually large are also difficult to accurately price. The so-called “white elephant” — a home grander and more spacious than less expensive surrounding properties — can also cause some appraiser head scratching. “Green” homes that require consideration of projected energy savings can prove tricky on the valuation front as well.

Even if lenders are willing to extend financing for such unusual homes, they will often offer far less than is typical with a more run-of-the-mill property for a given area. As a result, buyers should brace themselves to cough up more than the usual 20 percent down payment, Tim Sickinger, a senior vice president of Atlantic Residential Mortgage in Westport, Conn. told the Times.

Smaller banks typically are more willing to offer up financing for unusual properties, as these financial institutions are increasingly keen on growing their market share, according to the Times. [NYT]Julie Strickland


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Clockwise from left: One Vanderbilt, 111 Wall Street, 520 and 524 Broadway (SL Green and Google Maps)
These were the largest Manhattan real estate loans in June
These were the largest Manhattan real estate loans in June
Tomo Co-Founders Carey Armstrong and Greg Schwartz (LinkedIn via Schwartz and Armstrong, Getty)
Tomo digital mortgage startup enters Texas, Washington markets
Tomo digital mortgage startup enters Texas, Washington markets
Shares of Rocket Cos and LoanDepot rose while shares Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac plunged after Supreme Court ruling (Unsplash)
For mortgage sector stocks, Fannie and Freddie ruling was positive
For mortgage sector stocks, Fannie and Freddie ruling was positive
The pandemic disproportionately impacted unemployment rates for Black and Latino households, making them more likely to enter mortgage forbearance. (iStock)
Black and Latino homeowners left behind in mortgage refinancing wave
Black and Latino homeowners left behind in mortgage refinancing wave
JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon (Getty)
JPMorgan invests in private-label mortgage platform
JPMorgan invests in private-label mortgage platform
Kairos’ founder Ankur Jain (Getty)
Startup charts a (long) path toward homeownership
Startup charts a (long) path toward homeownership
Millions of homeowners remain vulnerable as forbearance winds down
Millions of homeowners remain vulnerable as forbearance winds down
Millions of homeowners remain vulnerable as forbearance winds down
Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell (Getty)
Traders eye Fed pullback on mortgage bonds
Traders eye Fed pullback on mortgage bonds
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...