KPF’s design for One Vanderbilt not so grand: architecture review

Work marred by overly busy, almost chaotic, surface

TRD New York /
Sep.September 26, 2014 01:30 PM

Regarding SL Green’s controversial plans to put a sky-scraper on the southwest corner of 43rd and Vanderbilt Avenue: I am surprised, for starters, that Landmarks Preservation Commission would ever allow the existing building to come down. It is a pleasant, if not great building dating from the 1920s. In fact, Landmarks has put the kaibosh on scores of better-designed structures than One Vanderbilt — and often to preserve less interesting old buildings than this.

My initial reaction to the plans for the 67-story One Vanderbilt was disappointment.

It’s just another deconstructed tower in Midtown. It’s main point of interest is that the building revives the general terms of Daniel Libeskind’s initial design for the Freedom Tower at One World Trade Center.

But then I learned that it was designed by Kohn Pedersen Fox, which gave me pause. It was not the name that impressed me so much as the general excellence of the firm’s work to date. What’s more, I have been wrong about them before, especially when I based my assessment of 505 Fifth Avenue on initial renderings. As with all of the firm’s work, that building is extremely well made and more elegant in design that I had anticipated.

Knowing that at KPF is behind this latest project (which, at 1450 feet, aspires to be the second tallest in the city), I have no doubt that the quality of the workmanship will make its pleasant to inhabit and pleasant to walk past at street level.

Still, the general design feels too chaotic. This is not the creative chaos of the deconstructivist idiom, but rather the chaos brought by the numerous ideas that seem to elude the designer’s complete control. Beside the tangle of masses across the entire height of the building and the prosthetic accretions and subtractions that mark its busy surface, there is a listless use of curtain-walls, ribbon windows, mullions and infill to provide texture to that surface.

In short, KPF can do better.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
The Daily News Building at 220 East 42nd Street and SL Green CEO Marc Holliday (Credit: Getty Images)

SL Green puts Daily News building up for sale

SL Green puts Daily News building up for sale
SL Green snags private-equity firm at One Vanderbilt

SL Green snags private-equity firm at
One Vanderbilt

SL Green snags private-equity firm at
One Vanderbilt
SL Green’s locks in big bank lease at Hudson Yards redevelopment site

SL Green’s locks in big bank lease at
Hudson Yards redevelopment site

SL Green’s locks in big bank lease at
Hudson Yards redevelopment site
SL Green CEO Marc Holliday, One Madison Avenue and Hines Group CEO Jeffrey Hines (SL Green; Hines via Sanjeev Verma/Hindustan Times via Getty Images)

SL Green sells half of One Madison to Hines, NPS of Korea

SL Green sells half of One Madison to Hines, NPS of Korea
SL Green CEO Marc Holliday and CFO Matthew DiLiberto (Credit: SL Green)

SL Green preparing $1B coronavirus cushion

SL Green preparing $1B coronavirus cushion
SL Green's Mark Holliday with Industry City in Brooklyn and 95 Morton Street (Credit: Industry City; SL Green; Google Maps)

SL Green in talks to sell loans to CIM, Rockwood

SL Green in talks to sell loans to CIM, Rockwood
10 East 53rd Street and SL Green's Marc Holliday (Credit: TPG Architecture, Sl Green)

SL Green snags $220M refi for Midtown East office tower

SL Green snags $220M refi for Midtown East office tower
1185 Sixth Avenue (Credit: Google Maps)

3 workers test positive for coronavirus at 3 SL Green office towers

3 workers test positive for coronavirus at 3 SL Green office towers
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...