Brunner’s Bed-Stuy rental deal complicated by suit

Investor and his partner Mandel say seller “unjustifiably” claims they’re in default

TRD New York /
Aug.August 31, 2015 01:30 PM

UPDATED, Sept. 2, 8:25 p.m.: A lawsuit threatens to disrupt the sale of a Bedford-Stuyvesant development site slated for 196 rental units.

Joseph Brunner, Abe Mandel and Isaac Hager signed a contract late last year to pay $22.5 million for the site at 1101-1123 Myrtle Avenue, near Lewis Avenue. Hager, who is affiliated with Cornell Realty Management and North True Construction, had filed plans in December for a nine-story, 172,000-square-foot property to be designed by architect Karl Fischer.

Brunner and Mandel, who run Bruman Realty LLC, then filed a $35.5 million lawsuit in July against the seller, jeweler Simon Alishaev of Alishaev Brothers. They accuse him of “unjustifiably” claiming that they are in default under the terms of the contract, and of setting an unreasonable closing date.

Brunner and Mandel couldn’t be reached for comment, while Aaron Ambalu, lawyer for Alishaev, declined to comment.

Jeffrey Zwick, lawyer for the would-be buyers, claims they submitted a $7.5 million wire deposit. “We expect the seller to perform under the terms of the contract,” Zwick told TRD.

According to a stipulation filed Aug. 18, Alishaev agreed not to sell or enter a contract with another party until after Sept. 1. But he remains accused of breaching his contract with Brunner and Mandel.

Sources said Hager is handling the design and layout for the project. The site is comprised of three parcels – a one-story office-and-retail building and two vacant lots.

The buyers would pay roughly $131 per buildable square foot.

Alishaev has owned the parcels since 2009, when he paid $11.1 million, records show.

In addition to the residential component, plans also call for 19,000 square feet of commercial space, including a grocery store or deli on the ground floor.

No brokers are involved in the deal, sources said.

Brunner, who doubles as a developer and lender throughout Brooklyn, has been actively scooping up development sites of late. He bought seven buildings in Greenpoint for $317 per buildable square foot and, in partnership with Mandel, is in contract for two buildings in Williamsburg for a pricey $700 per buildable square foot.

Correction: A previous version of this story incorrectly identified the source of a quote attributed to the site’s owner. 

Related Articles

From left: Adamson Associates' Alan Tearle, Handel Architects' Gary Handel, Aufgang Architects' Ariel Aufgang (Credit: Getty Images, iStock, Adamson, Aufgang)

These architects designed the most new dev in NYC this year

Reverend Al Sharpton and 1215 Fulton Street (Credit: Getty Images and Google Maps)

Historic Slave Theater site will soon be co-living property

871 Bushwick Avenue in Brooklyn (Credit: Google Maps)

Joseph Brunner lands $130M refi for massive Bushwick rental building

Bedford-Stuyvesant homes (Credit: Wikipedia)

Seller’s remorse: Bed-Stuy family claims they were duped into selling home at far below its value

Here’s what the $10M-$20M NYC investment sales market looked like last week

Here’s what the $10M-$20M NYC investment sales market looked like last week

Architect Karl Fischer dead at 70

Architect Karl Fischer dead at 70

Learning and earning: Hasidic Brooklyn’s real estate machers

Learning and earning: Hasidic Brooklyn’s real estate machers

Alchemy purchases 9-building Bed-Stuy portfolio for $25M

Alchemy purchases 9-building Bed-Stuy portfolio for $25M