Moinian sues HPD over Sky’s 421a status

Debate brews over construction start date of 2008 or 2014

TRD New York /
Nov.November 10, 2016 02:00 PM
Renderings of 605 West 42nd Street and Joseph Moinian

Renderings of 605 West 42nd Street and Joseph Moinian

The Moinian Group, the developer behind the 61-story rental tower Sky, is suing the New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development to reverse the agency’s decision regarding the project’s 421a benefits.

What’s under debate is when construction on the Midtown project at 605 West 42nd Street officially launched. Moinian claims it began in 2014, but HPD recognizes the construction start date as June 2008, which significantly decreases the tax incentives Moinian would receive under the 421a program, according to a petition filed Wednesday in New York State Supreme Court.

Under 421a, developers receive tax exemptions for eligible buildings for a construction period of up to three years, followed by decreasing tax abatements over a period of 10 to 25 years depending on various factors. If Sky began construction in 2014, Moinian would still be within the three-year construction phase and the project would be tax-exempt.

The current proposal for Sky is based on plans approved by the Department of Buildings in October 2014, which differ significantly different from a previous design approved in 2008. The new building is 15 stories taller, spans 1.2 million square feet instead of 880,976, and includes 1,175 units instead of 764. The new building is also expected to include 235 affordable units and a public health club featuring multiple swimming pools, neither of which were included in earlier plans.

According to Moinian TRData LogoTINY, that should make him eligible to 421a benefits beginning in 2014, putting him early in the benefit cycle.

Construction on the earlier version began in 2008 but was stalled in 2009. A previous 421a application for the site, submitted by Moinian in 2012, cited the 2008 start date.

Moinian is seeking a court order annulling the HPD’s determination and accepting an official construction start date of October 2014.

Neither Moinian nor the HPD responded to requests for comment.

Related Articles

Jay Martin, James Whelan and Joe Strasburg

Rent-pocalypse 2.0: Real estate industry reacts to tenant demands

The issue came to light after some owners realized they were incorrectly billed in June (Credit: iStock)

“A big, big, big success,” NYC Finance Department says of new system that overcharged building owners on property tax

With the elimination of vacancy decontrol, landlords can't deregulate units in buildings receiving 421a until the tax break expires (Credit: iStock)

Collateral damage? Real estate sounds alarm on rent regs’ impact on condos, 421a

100 Riverside Boulevard is one property whose tax abatements are ending

With 421a ending, more condo owners are selling their apartments

Brooklyn developer overcharged tenants by more than $1M at new 421a building: lawsuit

For developers who love the old 421a, stalled construction sites are ripe for the picking

With huge refi, Moinian to take complete control of 3 Columbus Circle

PHOTOS: Inside Moinian’s 2018 holiday bash