Shelter Island property owners call new rental rules “devastating”

Aug.August 27, 2017 05:00 PM

The price tags on posh Shelter Island pads are on the rise.

New rental regulations introduced to Shelter Island this spring are depriving middle-class residents of the tony East End vacation spot of essential income, locals complain.

In April, rules stating that no home can be rented more than once in a 14-day period were introduced. They were meant to help preserve the island’s quite culture and stay the influx of rowdy partiers. But many on the island say that the new rules could mean that they will have to say goodbye to their homes.


“I’m paralyzed with anxiety about how to survive the winter,” Julia Weisenberg, one of six homeowners who filed a lawsuit last week to repeal the vacation-rental law, told the New York Post. “What’s really going to ‘destroy’ this island for families is this law.”

The new rules also require landlords to get a license, keep a registry of their guests and have tenants sign a “good neighbor” brochure.

But those behind the law aren’t shedding any tears for their poorer neighbors. They say it is essential to keep summer revelers at bay.

“It’s going to be another Montauk, and we don’t want that,” local Joseph Kronwitt said. [NYP] Christopher Cameron

Related Articles

Robert Futterman charged with DUI in Hamptons car crash

Robert Futterman charged with DUI in Hamptons car crash

Totally accurate predictions for the long-term impacts of coronavirus on real estate: office-to-mall conversions, wide elevators and more (Credit: iStock)

Small Talk: Wildly Accurate Predictions for the Long Term Impacts of Coronavirus on Real Estate

Brian Chesky (Credit: Richard Bord/Getty Images)

Airbnb announces relief package. Some hosts say it’s not enough

The superrich are fleeing NYC in droves, pushing South Fork rental prices way up. (Credit: Sue via Flickr)

“I’ve got a blank check. Make it happen:” Hamptons brokers on the great coronavirus migration

Data show where people are looking for Airbnbs, and where they are fleeing, as #COVID19 spreads across the US (Credit: AirDNA)

Escaping Covid-19: Here’s where people are fleeing — and avoiding

Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky (Photo by Mike Cohen/Getty Images for The New York Times)

Airbnb calls for federal aid as hosts voice anger over policy changes

With the kids out of school, wealthy families look to weather the coronavirus storm in rentals out east (Credit: iStock)

The 1% are shelling out $400K on Hamptons rentals as NYC shuts down

(Credit: iStock)

The South Fork is having its worst year since the financial crisis