Judge annuls DFS’ “absurd” anti-marketing rules for title companies

Title companies sued to block regs in February

New York /
Jul.July 05, 2018 05:45 PM

(Credit: Getty Images)

New York title insurers can get back to schmoozing.

In a major victory for agents, closers and underwriters, a judge on Thursday annulled the strict anti-marketing regulations enacted earlier this year by the Department of Financial Services. The rules had been an attempt to crack down on excessive wining and dining in the industry, but insurance companies and their representatives called it a death knell to their business.

In a 15-page decision, Judge Eileen Rakower sided with the industry and challenged DFS’ use of a state insurance law to prevent companies from engaging in ordinary marketing activities.

According to Rakower, the law was intended to prevent kickbacks and commission rebates. It was not, she wrote, “intended to prohibit ordinary marketing and entertainment expenses.” To construe the law otherwise, she added, would be “to hold that the Legislature intended to prohibit title insurance corporations from marketing themselves for business — an absurd proposition.”

In a statement, DFS Superintendent Maria Vullo said the agency would appeal. The regulations provide “a necessary supervisory tool to ensure appropriate market conduct and to protect New York consumers,” she said.

DFS rolled out the new regulations in January, banning title companies from treating clients to meals and entertainment.

But in February, the New York State Land Title Association, along with Great American Title Agency Inc. and Venture Title Agency, filed an Article 78 petition to challenge the rules.

In court documents, they challenged the DFS’ authority and said the regulations would “wreak havoc” on title companies. “DFS must be stopped,” they wrote.

In addition to anti-marketing provisions, the regulations also banned tipping for title closers, independent contractors who attend closings and ensure all documents and checks are in order.

“We are pleased with the court’s decision and thankful that title closers can now return to a situation where their means of making a living is not in jeopardy,” said Eric Horowitz, an attorney with Zane and Rudofsky who filed an amicus brief on behalf of title closers in March. NYSLTA declined to comment.

Over the past few months, the state Senate has passed bills easing the regulations and allowing title companies to continue buying clients coffee and taking them to lunch. In Thursday’s decision, Rakower said if DFS wants to regulate marketing and entertainment expenses, the Legislature may pass new regulation.

“Indeed, the Legislature is in the best position to balance any social and economic ramifications purportedly created by certain practices in the title insurance industry,” she said.

 
 

Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Keith Powers, Democratic District 4 representative on the New York City Council, in front of 45 East 45th Street (Getty Images, The Roosevelt Hotel, iStock/Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
Local lawmakers aim to landmark shuttered Roosevelt Hotel
Local lawmakers aim to landmark shuttered Roosevelt Hotel
From left: Steven Roth, chief executive officer, Vornado Realty Trust; Kathy Hochul, governor of New York; Stephen Ross, chairman and founder, The Related Companies (Getty Images, iStock/Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
Real estate showers Hochul with cash
Real estate showers Hochul with cash
Gov. Kathy Hochul Lays Out Replacement 421a (Getty Images, iStock, , Illustration by Kevin Cifuentes for The Real Deal)
New name, same basic idea: Hochul pitches 421a reform
New name, same basic idea: Hochul pitches 421a reform
(iStock/Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
Hochul plan for resi towers is tall order
Hochul plan for resi towers is tall order
From left: Letitia James, attorney general of New York; Donald Trump, 45th U.S. president (Getty Images, Wikipedia/ChrisRuvolo, iStock/Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
New York AG alleges Trump altered values at 6 properties
New York AG alleges Trump altered values at 6 properties
From left: Joseph Riever and Christopher Marte (Elizabeth Street Garden, New York City Campaign Finance Board)
After 10-year saga, judge’s delay keeps senior housing unbuilt
After 10-year saga, judge’s delay keeps senior housing unbuilt
From left: Kathy Hochul, governor of New York; Robert Mujica, director of the budget for New York State (Getty Images, iStock/Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
$2B in Hochul budget could fund rent relief
$2B in Hochul budget could fund rent relief
Housing Justice for All’s Cea Weaver and Rent Stabilization Association’s Joseph Strasburg (Illustration by Ilya Hourie for The Real Deal)
The benefits and costs of “good cause” eviction
The benefits and costs of “good cause” eviction
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...