Debunking Hamptons pricing: Where can you get the best mansion deals?

Analysis tries to bring order to the chaos

New York /
Jul.July 17, 2018 09:00 AM

A Sag Harbor mansion (Credit: Matthew Korn Architecture)

Buying in the Hamptons is not exactly a science: Prices don’t obey the regular rules of the market.

Because homes in the Hamptons are often second-homes for summer getaways, the prices don’t always adhere to usual indicators, like size and location. Still, using data from Zillow, Bloomberg looked at sales in six major Long Island vacation destinations from May 2017 to May 2018 — in an attempt to find where the best deals are located. According to the analysis, Sag Harbor was the most expensive of all the areas with a median price per square foot of $1,297. Bridgehampton followed with a median price per square foot of $871, and Southhampton was third with $706. After that was Westhampton Beach with a median price per square foot of $684, Shelter Island with $548 and Hampton Bays with $388.

The high prices in Sag Harbor could be attributed to particularly expensive homes that recently sold along the waterfront. Still, for to $2 to $3 million, a buyer can get a small cottage on maybe a quarter of an acre that needs work, said Mala Sander, a Corcoran broker who’s based in Sag Harbor. On Shutter Island that money can take you much further: “three-quarters of an acre, with about a 6,000-square-foot house in mint condition with a pool, guest cottage, and garage,” said Seth Madore, a broker for Corcoran who is based on Shelter Island.

“I deal in the world of whims and wants, not needs,” he said. “It’s a second, third, fourth home market. The people here don’t need to sell, and the buyers don’t need to buy.” [Bloomberg] — Kathryn Brenzel


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
From left: 944 Fifth Avenue, 67-69 East 93rd Street and 15 East 88th Street (Google Maps)
Three Manhattan sellers aim high asking $25M+ for luxury pads
Three Manhattan sellers aim high asking $25M+ for luxury pads
FiDi condo supply is through the roof as workers delay office return. (Getty)
FiDi condo glut is through the roof
FiDi condo glut is through the roof
eXp CEO Glenn Sanford (eXp, iStock)
Virtual broker eXp Realty has another record quarter
Virtual broker eXp Realty has another record quarter
RSA's Joseph Strasburg and Judge Lawrence Marks (Getty, Strasburg via Jeffersons Siegel)
Landlord group challenges state eviction ban
Landlord group challenges state eviction ban
Redfin CEO Glenn Kelman (Getty, Redfin)
Pocket listings exclude minority homebuyers, Redfin CEO says
Pocket listings exclude minority homebuyers, Redfin CEO says
(378 West End, 300 West and 567 Ocean Avenue, Getty)
April was best month for new condo sales in 5 years
April was best month for new condo sales in 5 years
As the economy rebounds, rental prices are following suit. With the eviction ban recently overturned, that spells trouble for tenants who are struggling to make ends meet. (iStock)
Rents rise across country as economy rebounds
Rents rise across country as economy rebounds
Howard Lorber (iStock, Getty)
Elliman reports $14M quarterly profit, 65% revenue jump
Elliman reports $14M quarterly profit, 65% revenue jump
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...