This calculator shows how the new mansion, transfer taxes work

We crunched the numbers to see what the taxes would've been on 2018's top deals

TRD New York /
Apr.April 02, 2019 07:00 AM
The "mansion tax" ranges from .25 to 2.9 percent (Credit: iStock)

The new taxes take effect July 1 of this year (Credit: iStock)

Instead of introducing an annual pied-à-terre tax, a measure dreaded by much of the city’s real estate industry, the state’s 2019-2020 budget includes an expansion of the “mansion tax,” a one-time levy on residential sales, along with a heftier transfer tax.

The “mansion tax” ranges from .25 to 2.9 percent, in addition to the existing 1 percent tax that is already collected on residential properties sold for $1 million or more. The budget also included an extra .25 percent transfer tax on residential properties that sell for more than $3 million. The new taxes take effect July 1 of this year and are projected to generate $365 million in revenue.

To get an idea of what these taxes would look like for individual sales, we calculated the mansion and transfer taxes on the top 10 most expensive residential closings of 2018 in the city — both what they would’ve been last year and what they would look like if the new rules applied. If these 10 units closed with the new tax rules in place, the city and state would have collectively received $18.1 million in additional revenue. The average difference between the actual and hypothetical tax bills for these deals was $1.8 million.

(This analysis does not include Ken Griffin’s record-breaking $238 million deal in January at 220 Central Park South, but under the new tax rates the city and state would have hypothetically collected $14.3 million; under the old system, the bill was $6.9 million.)

1. 520 Park Avenue, DPH60; $74 million
Old taxes: $2.1M
Mansion tax: $740,000
Transfer tax: $1.4M

New taxes: $4.4M
Mansion tax: $2.88M
Transfer tax: $1.5M

2. 9-13 East 75th Street; $74 million
Old taxes: $2.1M
Mansion tax: $740,000
Transfer tax: $1.4M

New taxes: $4.4M
Mansion tax: $2.88M
Transfer tax: $1.5M

3. 432 Park Avenue, Unit 77A and 77B; $64 million
Old taxes: $1.8M
Mansion tax: $640,000
Transfer tax: $256,000

New taxes: $3.8M
Mansion tax: $2.5M
Transfer tax: $1.3M

4. 520 Park Avenue, DPH52; $62 million
Old taxes: $1.8M
Mansion tax: $620,000
Transfer tax: $1.1M

New taxes: $3.7M
Mansion tax: $2.4M
Transfer tax: $1.3M

5. The Getty, PH; $59.1 million
Old taxes: $1.7M
Mansion tax: $591,000
Transfer tax: $1.1M

New taxes: $3.5M
Mansion tax: $2.3M
Transfer tax: $1.2M

6. 70 Vestry Street, PH; $56 million
Old taxes: $1.6M
Mansion tax: $560,000
Transfer tax: $1M

New taxes: $3.3M
Mansion tax: $2.2M
Transfer tax: $1.1M

7. One57, Unit 85; $54 million
Old taxes: $1.5M
Mansion tax: 540,000
Transfer tax: $985,500

New taxes: $3.2M
Mansion tax: $2.1M
Transfer tax: $1.1M

8. 15 Central Park West; $50 million
Old taxes: $1.4M
Mansion tax: $500,000
Transfer tax: $912.500

New taxes: $3M
Mansion tax: $1.95M
Transfer tax: $1M

9. 443 Greenwich, Penthouse A; $43.8 million
Old taxes: $1.2M
Mansion tax: $438,000
Transfer tax: $799,350

New taxes: $2.6M
Mansion tax: $1.7M
Transfer tax: $908,850

10. 160 Leroy Street; $43.5 million
Old taxes: $1.2M
Mansion tax: $435,000
Transfer tax: $793,875

New taxes: $2.6M
Mansion tax: $1.7M
Transfer tax: $902,625

If these 10 units closed with the new tax rules in place, the city and state would have collectively received $18.1 million in additional revenue.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Seth Campbell (iStock)

Keller Williams to cut ties with top franchise owner following sexual harassment allegations

Keller Williams to cut ties with top franchise owner following sexual harassment allegations
Ghost Towers

NYC’s ghost towers: How many Manhattan luxury condos are owned by people who don’t live there?

NYC’s ghost towers: How many Manhattan luxury condos are owned by people who don’t live there?
Manhattan homes flooded the market last week but buyers are nowhere to be found 

Manhattan homes for sale nearly doubled last week

Manhattan homes for sale nearly doubled last week
Competition for affordable housing in New York City is highest among those who need affordable housing most (Getty, iStock)

Poorest face worst odds in city’s housing lotteries

Poorest face worst odds in city’s housing lotteries
511 Macon Street and 70 Washington Street in Brooklyn (Courtesy Compass; Streeteasy)

Brooklyn’s luxury market slumped as in-person showings began

Brooklyn’s luxury market slumped as in-person showings began
Industry experts and insiders swap theories on how much of a discount New York City homebuyers should expect if they buy during the Covid-19 pandemic. (iStock)

Insiders dish on pandemic pricing for NYC homes

Insiders dish on pandemic pricing for NYC homes
Caliber CEO Sanjiv Das (iStock)

Lone Star affiliate reaches $17M settlement with NY homeowners

Lone Star affiliate reaches $17M settlement with NY homeowners
Hundreds of Manhattan sellers have returned their properties to the market, but have buyers come back? (iStock)

Manhattan listings are at pre-Covid levels but deals aren’t: Report

Manhattan listings are at pre-Covid levels but deals aren’t: Report
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...