City overvalued Podolsky portfolio by $26M, uncovered docs show

Administration used generous appraisal to justify $173M price tag

TRD New York /
Apr.April 17, 2019 06:30 PM
Comptroller Scott Stringer and Mayor Bill de Blasio with 710 East 243rd Street in the Bronx (Credit: Getty Images and Google Maps)

Comptroller Scott Stringer and Mayor Bill de Blasio with 710 East 243rd Street in the Bronx (Credit: Getty Images and Google Maps)

The city’s $173 million purchase of 21 buildings from the Podolsky brothers has attracted scrutiny because of the sellers’ past, their political connections and the price tag itself. A late Monday document dump is poking even more holes in the official version of events.

According to 2,000 pages of documents subpoenaed by City Comptroller Scott Stringer, City Hall overvalued the buildings by $26 million using faulty rent assumptions, the New York Post reported.

“It’s a shame that it took a subpoena from the Comptroller’s Office for the City to release what should have been public information about a multimillion dollar deal,” a Stringer spokesperson told the Post. Stringer has been a prominent critic of the deal.

The $173 million the city paid for the “cluster sites” was already a considerable markup from their official valuation of $143 million. City officials say the price rose during the course of negotiations, and Mayor de Blasio has argued that the threat of a legal battle justified the increase.

The newly released documents make even $143 million look overly generous. They show that Law Department appraisers assumed that about half of the units would qualify for higher rents through a Department of Social Services program, although no such plans are actually in place.

In one 25-unit Bronx building, for example, the Law Department’s appraisal calculated that 13 DSS-subsidized apartments would pull in $1,637 per month in rent. The eight rent-stabilized units generate just $991 per month.

The portfolio’s total value, assuming that all 729 apartments are used for rent-stabilized housing, comes out to $117 million instead.

The city briefly halted plans to buy the Podolsky portfolio in January, when it emerged that their firm was under federal investigation for possible financial crimes. The brothers have a reputation as slumlords, having pleaded guilty to a tenant harassment scheme in the 1980s.

The deal also raised eyebrows due to the fact that the Podolskys’ lawyer in the deal, Frank Carone, is a longtime de Blasio ally and fundraiser. Furthermore, the Post reported last week that 17 of the 21 buildings have “immediately hazardous” housing code violations. [NYP]Kevin Sun

Related Articles

60 East 93rd Street and Carlton Hobbs (Credit: Google Maps and Getty Images)

Why a $68M townhouse listing was abruptly pulled off the market

Zillow President Jeremy Wacksman

Zillow launches its high-stakes home-flipping business in LA

From left: the Ritz-Carlton, 32 East 1st Street, 560 West 24th Street, 301 East 80th Street and 32 West 85th Street

Five priciest homes new to market include 1897 townhouse

Melania La Rocca

Buildings commissioner talks priorities in final de Blasio years

Ed Gilligan and 3 East 94th Street (Credit: Getty Images, Compass)

Don’t leave home without $21M: Amex exec’s widow sells townhouse

From left: Jed Wilder, Bess Freedman, Richard Grossman, Josh Sarnell and Adam Mahfouda (Credit: Emily Assiran) 

Agents to StreetEasy: The fee is too damn high

40 East 72nd Street (Credit: Google Maps)

Nightmare on E. 72nd Street raises question: Are small condos risky?

Jed Garfield of Leslie J. Garfield; Richard Grossman, president of Halstead Real Estate; Sarah Saltzberg, principal broker and CEO of Bohemia Realty Group; Douglas Elliman’s Howard Lorber

NYC brokers slam bias, promise action after Newsday exposé