City targets building loophole used by Billionaires’ Row developers

The city wants to count voids 30 feet and taller toward a project's max size

TRD New York /
Apr.April 22, 2019 08:45 AM
Central Park Tower at 217 West 57th Street and 432 Park Avenue (Credit: Wikipedia and Pixabay)

Central Park Tower at 217 West 57th Street and 432 Park Avenue (Credit: Wikipedia and Pixabay)

Manhattan developers for years have boosted the heights of their towers by using a loophole in the city’s zoning laws.

Developers have included what’s known as mechanical voids — unoccupied floors with mechanical and structural equipment — to dedicate more room at the top of a project, where residents will pay higher prices for better views.

But now city officials are looking to close this loophole through rules that would make unusually large mechanical spaces count toward a building’s height limit, according to the New York Times. The proposal would count mechanical floors greater than 30 feet tall (up from a proposed 25 feet in January) toward the maximum size of the building, which would mainly apply to buildings by Central Park and Lower Manhattan.

But the real estate industry has criticized this idea as misguided and obstructive. Developer Harry Macklowe told the Times that he supports the attempt to firm up rules around mechanical spaces but disputed that he had taken advantage of the current loophole to make 432 Park Avenue taller than it would have been otherwise.

“It offends me,” he said, “because we created a very nice building that fits into the skyline perfectly.”

Silvan Marcus, 432 Park’s structural engineer, told the Times that without the mechanical floors, the tower would noticeably sway.

Gary Barnett — whose Central Park Tower will have 20 percent of such space — said the city’s proposal was reasonable, but the voids in his project were necessary for amenity space and retail tenant Nordstrom. [NYT] – Eddie Small

Related Articles

These are the tallest towers underway in NYC

These are the tallest towers underway
in NYC

A new competition asks what would houses on Mars look like (Credit: Getty Images, Pixabay)

Architecture’s final frontier: Here’s what houses on Mars might look like

From left: The Blau and Berg Company's Karine Blanc, TD and Partners' Nana Duncan and Lemor Development Group's Kenneth Morrison (Credit: Blauberg, TD+Partners and Lemor)

Black developers say partnerships aren’t always equal

Stanford White

The great works and untimely death of New York architect Stanford White

85 4th Avenue in Brooklyn (Credit: Google Maps)

New details of Boerum Hill’s next big project unveiled

TF Cornerstone president Frederick Elghanayan and 595 Dean Street (Credit: CityRealty, Google Maps)

TF Cornerstone’s Prospect Heights two-tower project unveiled

Miki Naftali and 1045 Madison Avenue (Credit: Getty Images, Google Maps)

Naftali accused of violating zoning laws at UES development

Harry Macklowe, Linda Macklowe and 432 Park Avenue (Credit: Getty Images)

The latest in Harry Macklowe’s divorce: Linda’s appeal killed in court