Howard Hughes faces more backlash at Seaport. This time, it’s over toxic contamination concerns

Lot at 250 Water Street was former home of 19th century thermometer factory

Jun.June 07, 2019 10:00 AM
250 Water Street and Howard Hughes Corporation CEO David Weinreb (Credit: Google Maps)

250 Water Street and Howard Hughes Corporation CEO David Weinreb (Credit: Google Maps)

Howard Hughes Corporation is again facing community backlash in the South Street Seaport again. But this time, it isn’t purely over a new development.

A parking lot that the developer recently purchased at 250 Water Street may contain elemental mercury under the asphalt, according to the New York Times. The mercury remains would be leftover from a thermometer factory that existed on the site in the 1800s, and Howard Hughes applied to the state’s brownfield cleanup program last November for the site.

The company paid $180 million for the one-acre property — which has 290,000 buildable square feet — and has already expressed interest in transferring air rights to the parking lot site from other properties.

But the neighborhood’s Community Board 1 recently passed a resolution that calls for nothing to happen on the parking lot until an approved plan is in place for land use.

Residents have long resisted projects that they say would contribute to the neighborhood losing its historic character, while some development experts say the city cannot afford to let sites like the parking lot stay undeveloped when there is such a strong need for housing.

Howard Hughes has clashed with the community before, including over a since discarded proposal to build a 50-story hotel and condo on the waterfront and swapping plans for a parklike roof at Pier 17 with plans for a concert venue.

But concerns about overdevelopment in general and issues with mercury at 250 Water Street remain high.

Anthony Carpi, an environmental toxicologist at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice, said that there has not been a comprehensive study done of the parking lot yet, so no one knows if “the site is slightly contaminated or grotesquely contaminated or something in between.” [NYT] — Eddie Small

Related Articles

Howard Hughes Corporation CEO Paul Layne with former CEO David Weinreb (Credit: Getty Images)

As Howard Hughes tries to right ship, Seaport remains an albatross

Howard Hughes CEO David R. Weinreb and South Street Seaport (Credit: NYCgo)

Amid talks of company sale, Howard Hughes lands $250M loan for Seaport project

From left: CEO David Weinreb and Chairman Bill Ackman

Developer Howard Hughes mulls sale amid continued financial uncertainty

The site (left) and a rendering of 80 South Street (Credit: Google Maps; rendering via YIMBY by ATCHAIN)

China Oceanwide takes out $175M loan against supertall Seaport site

Ward Village (Credit: Howard Hughes Corporation)

Hawaii’s answer to Hudson Yards: This 60-acre megaproject in Honolulu

(Credit: Rockwell Group courtesy LPC, illustration by Wons Noj via Wikimedia Commons)

Winter is coming: Rockwell Group to build pop-up “village” at Pier 17

Milstein lends $130M on Seaport site it long owned

Milstein lends $130M on Seaport site it long owned

Howard Hughes buys Milstein’s Seaport site for $180M

Howard Hughes buys Milstein’s Seaport site for $180M