Pols ponder NYCHA air rights sale for Gowanus

Opportunity for developers and public housing residents

Dec.December 18, 2019 03:00 PM
Stephen Levin, Brad Lander, 187 and 195 Hoyt Street (Credit: Google Maps, iStock)

Stephen Levin, Brad Lander, 187 and 195 Hoyt Street (Credit: Google Maps, iStock)

Developers already see a major opportunity in Gowanus: a gentrifying, underbuilt area with good subway access.

Letting local NYCHA developments sell their air rights could make it even sweeter for builders and for public housing residents, and the two City Council members who must approve say they will consider it.

The idea was outlined in a report from the Pratt Center for Community Development, which argues that the city needs to broaden the Gowanus rezoning plan to include three local NYCHA developments: Gowanus Houses, Wyckoff Gardens and 572 Warren Street.

The report proposes that the city let these NYCHA properties sell air rights to developers and use that money for repairs.

“By excluding Gowanus NYCHA developments from the rezoning boundary, the city prevents NYCHA from directly benefiting from the land use action and therefore risks exacerbating the existing inequalities between residents of public housing and the community’s wealthier and whiter neighbors,” the study says.

City Council members Brad Lander and Steve Levin both represent the area that would be affected by the rezoning, and both maintain that the plan needs to benefit the public housing developments. However, while they see letting NYCHA sell its air rights as a way to accomplish this, they do not view it as the only way.

“The bottom line, as we’ve said all along, is that the Gowanus rezoning must contribute significantly to addressing dilapidated conditions in the nearby public housing,” said Lander, who ran the Pratt Center before entering politics. “This is one very good way of doing that. We remain open to other ways if City Hall wants to propose different kinds of connections or subsidies.”

Levin has a similar stance, according to his spokeswoman Nicole Hunt. He does think that the NYCHA developments should be included in the rezoning area, but he sees letting the agency sell its air rights as just one option.

Representatives from City Hall and NYCHA did not respond to requests for comment.

Elena Conte, deputy director at the Pratt Center, said the group’s proposal to let NYCHA sell air rights already had one distinct advantage over other options for improving public housing in Gowanus: it is actually a concrete plan.

“Whether it’s the best idea or not, it’s an actual idea,” she said, “so that, I think, distinguishes it from what’s on the table elsewhere, which is lip service.”

The Gowanus rezoning has yet to enter the city’s seven-month public review process, which concludes with a City Council vote that will hinge on Lander and Levin’s say-so. Gowanus, a low-lying area nestled between Park Slope and Carroll Gardens, has seen property values increase in recent years as it transitions from an industrial area to residential, and plans to clean up the Gowanus Canal have inched forward. The canal has been declared a Superfund site.

Related Articles

East Williamsburg’s Williamsburg Houses and the Harlem River Houses and (Credit: Wikipedia)

NYCHA inks $1.5B deal to privatize management of 5,900 units

NYCHA housing (Credit: Wikipedia)

Feds launch investigation into landlords’ lead levels

State Senator Julia Salazar and Assemblymember Harvey Epstein (Credit: Getty Images)

Pols take aim at private equity with plan to tax mezz debt

 NYCHA CEO Gregory Russ and NYCHA houses (Credit: Minneapolis Public Housing Authority and Getty Images)

NYCHA head: Agency now needs $40B in repairs

Fort Independence Houses at 3340 Bailey Ave in Knightsbridge Heights (Credit: Google Maps)

NYCHA employee allegedly shot boss at Bronx housing project

NYCHA Chair Gregory Russ and NYCHA houses in Brooklyn (Credit: Minneapolis Public Housing Authority and Getty Images)

NYCHA residents are suing for 10 years of rent overcharges

Avery Hall principal Brian Ezra and a rendering of 204 Fourth Avenue (Credit: Avery Hall and Startup Columbia)

Avery Hall pays $30M for Gowanus site

Clockwise from left: 532-542 Union Street and 232 Third Avenue in Gowanus, Tavros' Colin Rankowitz and Avery Hall's Brian Ezra (Credit: Terra CRG, Tavros, Avery Hall)

Gowanus gold rush: Avery Hall, Tavros, Charney buy sites for $55M