Tenant advocates celebrate landlords’ having to pay broker fees

Supporters of new rule reject argument that rents must rise

New York /
Feb.February 07, 2020 07:00 AM
(Credit: iStock)

(Credit: iStock)

Broker fees have long been onerous and annoying for New York City apartment hunters, who often find themselves paying thousands of extra dollars even when they find a place on their own.

So when news broke Wednesday that the Department of State ruled the new rent law requires landlords, rather than tenants, to cover the fees of brokers retained by owners, tenant advocacy groups were ecstatic.

“For our members, especially who are homeless and perpetually unstably housed, this is hugely impactful,” said Paulette Soltani, political director at the activist group VOCAL New York. “I think fees, historically, just defined who had access to the rental market and who didn’t.”

She added, “This is just going to allow people to equally be able to find housing and not have to pay these exorbitant fees to get access.”

A standard broker fee is 15 percent of an apartment’s annual rent. The median rental price for a Manhattan apartment is about $3,500, which means a broker fee of $6,300 — payable upfront.

But even when the fee is far less, it can be a major burden for tenants. That was the case for tenant activist Winsome Pendergrass when she had to pay a broker $450 upon moving into a Flatbush apartment in 2010.

“It’s a lot,” she said, “especially when you’re a single person, and you have kids that you have to take care of or other family members that are ill.”

She was thrilled with the new rule requiring landlords to pay, saying that tenants are no longer “suffering in silence.”

“I know the landlords are not happy that we are calling them out,” she said, “and we are also calling out the politicians to say, ‘Hey, it’s about time you have our back.’”

Landlords say they plan to list and show apartments themselves or increase rents to cover the cost of brokers.

Soltani largely dismissed landlords’ claim about raising rents, saying that, by and large, they are doing well financially and are just intimidated by the potential impact of the new rule.

“I think that they are resisting any attempt to try to make our housing market more equitable for low-income people,” she said, “and so I don’t buy that argument at all.”

Jonathan Westin, executive director of New York Communities for Change, took the possibility that landlords would increase rents a bit more seriously, saying it just proved that the city needs to further reform its rent laws.

“This is why we believe in universal rent control,” he said. “This is why the rent victories last year were so important.”

He characterized landlords’ response as typical for the industry and said the consequences of this week’s ruling would likely be milder than landlords expect.

“When tenants get a victory, they cry the sky is going to fall, and as we saw with the current rent laws that were passed last year, it’s actually been a very good thing for New York City,” he said. “Evictions have gone down. It’s stabilized the industry, and we think this will have a very similar effect.”

Write to Eddie Small at [email protected]


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Five small landlords, represented by Randy Mastro, have sued New York attorney general Letitia James (Getty)
Lawsuit challenges New York eviction ban’s constitutionality
Lawsuit challenges New York eviction ban’s constitutionality
Redfin CEO Glenn Kelman and RentPath CEO Dhiren Fonseca (Redfin, RentPath/Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
Redfin to buy RentPath for $608M
Redfin to buy RentPath for $608M
From mid-March to the end of 2020, only 11,690 units citywide were affordable to essential workers (iStock)
Affordable, market-rate apartments surge 40%, but remain rare
Affordable, market-rate apartments surge 40%, but remain rare
Manhattan and Brooklyn renters sign leases in record numbers. (Getty)
Manhattan and Brooklyn renters sign leases in record numbers
Manhattan and Brooklyn renters sign leases in record numbers
Sen. Brian Kavanagh (Getty/Illustration by Alexis Manrodt for The Real Deal)
Landlords hail relief bill as end of “cancel rent”
Landlords hail relief bill as end of “cancel rent”
(iStock/Illustration by Alexis Manrodt for The Real Deal)
Rental payments improve in February after stimulus payments
Rental payments improve in February after stimulus payments
Clockwise from left: 248 McKibbin Street, 586 Hart Street and 345 Eldert Street (Google Maps)
Carnegie Management sued for damaging non-paying tenants’ credit
Carnegie Management sued for damaging non-paying tenants’ credit
New York Community Bank's Thomas Cangemi and headquarters in Westbury, New York (Photos via Google Maps; iStock)
Dramatic reversal buoys city’s biggest multifamily bank lender
Dramatic reversal buoys city’s biggest multifamily bank lender
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...