Three years after approval, BJ’s Wholesale Club remains unbuilt

Development on Staten Island wetlands faces lawsuit

New York /
Oct.October 28, 2020 09:15 AM
The development  site at 2324 Forest Avenue (Google Maps)

The development  site at 2324 Forest Avenue (Google Maps)

A BJ’s Wholesale Club project got the green light from Staten Island officials in 2017. It still has not happened.

The 226,000-square-foot development planned for Staten Island’s Mariners Harbor section, which has been approved to be built at 2324 Forest Avenue on 28 acres of wetlands, is the subject of a legal battle, the New York Times reported.

Although developer Charles Alpert has said the project will be home to at least 200 local jobs, protect 11 acres of the wetlands and include rain gardens and holding tanks to curb flooding, the 28-acre site helped save the area from Superstorm Sandy’s floods in 2012 and locals are hesitant to give it up.

The City Council, following the lead of local member Debi Rose, approved the plan, which Rose negotiated with Alpert. Borough President James Oddo backed it as well.

The Staten Island Coalition for Wetlands and Forests is suing the state Department of Environmental Conservation department to redo its assessment, which found that the approved project was better for the environment than what Alpert could build under the old zoning.

The lawsuit argues that the right to build on the land was never guaranteed, and that regulators should have compared the impact of the project with that of unbuilt land.

[NYT] — Sasha Jones


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Queens Borough President Donovan Richards in front of Willets Point. (Office of Queens Borough President, WikiMedia / Jim.henderson)
Willets Point redevelopment finally moves ahead
Willets Point redevelopment finally moves ahead
Francis Greenburger of Time Equities (Greenburger via Michael McWeeney; iStock)
Rental-to-condo conversions drop 80% after 2019 rent law: report
Rental-to-condo conversions drop 80% after 2019 rent law: report
Klövern executive Peeter Kinnunen, GDSNY CEO Michael Kirchmann and 407 Park Avenue (Klövern, GDSNY, Google Maps)
GDSNY, Klövern add 407 Park Avenue to project footprint for $31M
GDSNY, Klövern add 407 Park Avenue to project footprint for $31M
City Council Majority Leader Laurie Cumbo and 840 Atlantic Avenue (Getty, Google Maps)
Atlantic Avenue project gets haircut — and is rejected anyway
Atlantic Avenue project gets haircut — and is rejected anyway
Close to 80 hotels with more than 13,000 rooms plan to open in 2021. (iStock)
Big year seen for hotel openings, despite few visitors
Big year seen for hotel openings, despite few visitors
Total size of New York construction sites is smallest since 2010. (Getty)
New construction projects off to slow start in 2021
New construction projects off to slow start in 2021
Protestors in support of street vendors gather in Hudson Yards on May 7, 2021 (Getty)
“More churros, less cops”: Vendors and Related face off
“More churros, less cops”: Vendors and Related face off
Andrew Yang (Getty, iStock)
Yang targets vacant lots with $900 million tax plan
Yang targets vacant lots with $900 million tax plan
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...