Going in circles: Dueling New York Wheel lawsuits emerge

“Jurisdictional defect” spawns new lawsuits from EB-5 regional center, contractor

New York /
Nov.November 16, 2020 07:00 AM
New York Wheel (S9 Architecture|Perkins Eastman; Pixabay)

New York Wheel (S9 Architecture|Perkins Eastman; Pixabay)

The New York Wheel, the Staten Island waterfront project that would have been the largest observation wheel in the world, was declared dead two years ago. But legal wrangling over who is responsible for the project’s failure is far from over.

Last week, lawyers for both the project’s developer and contractor filed new lawsuits in federal and state court, respectively, after coming to the “unfortunate realization” that a prior suit, dating back to 2017, should not have been filed in federal court to begin with.

The problem, as laid out in a joint letter from both sides to the court, stems from a somewhat obscure “jurisdictional defect.” The group of investors behind the New York Wheel includes two minority members who primarily reside in Florida and California — which also happens to be where the project’s two Dutch contractors, Mammoet and Starneth, are located.

Lawyers with Dovel & Luner, who are now representing both the Wheel’s developers and the EB-5 regional center behind the project, CanAm Enterprises, say they only recently discovered this issue because they had relied on the analysis of their predecessors at first.

“As it turned out, this reliance was a serious mistake, as the prior analysis has now been shown to have been incomplete and inaccurate,” they wrote in the joint letter, noting that “no effort was made to withhold the truth or game the system.”

On Wednesday, Dovel & Luner filed a new suit in the Southern District of New York, with only CanAm — and not the developer — as plaintiff. Lawyers for Mammoet filed a suit of their own in New York State Supreme Court on the same day, seeking to move the entire dispute to a new venue. The three-year-old lawsuit, which was dismissed once in 2018 and re-opened in 2019, was dismissed again on Friday.

“We are confident that the NY Regional [i.e. CanAm] claim belongs in federal court and believe that any proceedings in state court should be deferred until after the federal court resolves the [CanAm] claim,” Jeff Eichmann of Dovel & Luner told The Real Deal in an email.

“Regardless of which courts preside over the various claims and counterclaims, NY Wheel [the developer] and [CanAm] are determined to hold the Defendants accountable for their breaches and recover the full measure of damages they are entitled to,” he added.

Counsel for Mammoet did not respond to a request for comment.

Allegations in the two new lawsuits, which mostly repeat claims made in the original 2017 suit, paint starkly different pictures of the circumstances that led to the New York Wheel’s demise.

In the developer and CanAm’s view, the story is simple: Mammoet and Starneth agreed to a fixed-price contract for the project, and if there were cost overruns, that was on them. “Due to their lack of diligence, they vastly underestimated how much it would cost them to build the Wheel,” CanAm’s new complaint says.

“The [contractors] eventually concluded that if they honored the contract, they would lose too much money. And so they tried to change the contract or escape it” — first by overcharging on their payment applications, and eventually by walking off altogether, the suit claims.

Mammoet, for its part, claims that it was the developers who did not live up to their numerous obligations. (Mammoet’s partner, observation wheel specialist Starneth, is currently in bankruptcy and not party to the new lawsuits.)

“[NY Wheel]’s refusal to acknowledge its contractual obligations, coupled with the fact that [NY Wheel] never invested the time or money to properly and adequately supervise, manage or finance the project, doomed the project from the outset,” Mammoet’s complaint states.

According to the contractor, the developer’s breaches of contract include supplying a construction site “with insufficient ground bearing capacity” and a foundation for the Wheel that was “inconsistent, unequal and excessive in its lateral stiffness,” as well as failing to secure a building permit.

The contractor entity that was working on the Wheel, Mammoet-Starneth LLC, declared bankruptcy in late 2017, and the parties came to a conditional settlement a few months later which led to the case being closed.

But that settlement depended on the developers’ ability “to obtain financing to complete the Wheel with its alternative builder,” which did not pan out, court filings show. The wheel’s parts were eventually sold at auction, and the developers re-opened the suit in August 2019, adding CanAm as a plaintiff in the process.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Dov Hertz and an aerial of 1900 South Avenue in Staten Island (Photos via Adam Pincus; Google Maps)
    Dov Hertz picks up Staten Island site for $65M
    Dov Hertz picks up Staten Island site for $65M
    Beny Steinmetz (Getty)
    Beny Steinmetz sentenced to five years in bribery scandal
    Beny Steinmetz sentenced to five years in bribery scandal
    From left: Ben Ashkenazy, 1991 Broadway, 2067 Broadway and Samuel Gindi (Getty; Google Maps)
    Ben Ashkenazy threatened to “go nuclear” on Century 21 family: lawsuit
    Ben Ashkenazy threatened to “go nuclear” on Century 21 family: lawsuit
    From left: Letitia James, Raphael Toledano and Josh Zegen with 223 East 5th Street and 325 East 12th Street (Getty, Google Maps)
    Madison Realty Capital to give Toledano tenants $1M in rent credits
    Madison Realty Capital to give Toledano tenants $1M in rent credits
    Peter Nygård (Getty)
    Retail magnate Peter Nygard hit with sex-trafficking indictment
    Retail magnate Peter Nygard hit with sex-trafficking indictment
    JDS Development's Michael Stern and 111 West 57th Street (JDS)
    JDS sues 111 West 57th contractor, insurer over shoddy work and “blunderbuss requests”
    JDS sues 111 West 57th contractor, insurer over shoddy work and “blunderbuss requests”
    The Mark's outdoor tent covering Zadig et Voltaire's storefront at East 77th St
    Restaurant, luxury retailer duke it out for sidewalk space: lawsuit
    Restaurant, luxury retailer duke it out for sidewalk space: lawsuit
    The Vitre at 302 East 96th Street with Wonder Works Construction’s Joseph Klaynberg and Daniel Klaynberg (Vitre NY; Wonder Works; iStock)
    Mezz lender takes control of Wonder Works’ UES condo
    Mezz lender takes control of Wonder Works’ UES condo
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...