Tribeca condo owners sue Magnum Real Estate, seeking $7.6M

Residents say law required developer to pay another $1.9M into reserve fund

New York /
Nov.November 19, 2020 07:00 AM
Magnum Real Estate's Ben Shaoul and 87 Leonard Street (Getty; StreetEasy)

Magnum Real Estate’s Ben Shaoul and 87 Leonard Street (Getty; StreetEasy)

Unit owners are accusing Ben Shaoul’s firm of stiffing them on reserve-fund money for the Tribeca condominium 87 Leonard. But the law might not be on their side.

The board of managers on Tuesday sued Shaoul’s Magnum Real Estate, alleging the developer was required to put another $1.89 million in sales proceeds into the building’s reserve fund. The board seeks that money plus fines and penalties for a total of about $7.6 million. The boutique project’s seven residences sold for between $6.6 million and $9.1 million from 2016 to 2018.

A reserve fund in a condominium is earmarked for building repairs and improvements. The case at 87 Leonard hinges on whether the law required 3 percent of sales to be contributed to the reserve fund, which may depend on what kind of building it was upon being converted to condominiums.

A state law refers to “conversions from rental to cooperative or condominium status.” Magnum’s attorneys at Starr Associates say the law doesn’t apply to 87 Leonard because it was converted from a commercial building.

The building had been an office when the previous owner, developer Anthony Morano of Ozymandius Realty, purchased it in 2004. Morano’s lender, a division of Deutsche Bank, took possession of the property in 2011 as the developer was trying to convert it into apartments.

Under the bank’s watch, plans for the residential conversion were approved in late 2011. Three years later, Magnum bought the property and completed the conversion into condos.

A deed from Magnum’s 2014 purchase of the building classifies it as an apartment building, but a check of records Wednesday by The Real Deal found no rental activity until 2018.

The condo board at 87 Leonard filed its complaint in New York Supreme Court, alleging that Magnum left just $65,000 in its reserve fund rather than nearly $2 million — 3 percent of projected sales of $65.4 million.

The board is also asking the court to award damages of at least the underfunded amount — $1.9 million — plus a fine of twice that sum ($3.8 million) and civil penalties of $1,000 a day, retroactive to July 2015, until its reserve fund is fully funded. As of Nov. 17, the day the board filed its complaint, those penalties would be around $1.95 million.

Magnum’s lawyers said they were confident the lawsuit would be discredited in court as “frivolous litigation” filed to “harass and maliciously injure the developer and its principals.”

Morrison Cohen partner Y. David Scharf, representing the condo board in the case, declined to comment.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Solly Assa blames homeless for damages at MAve Hotel, sues insurer
    Solly Assa blames homeless for damages at MAve Hotel, sues insurer
    Solly Assa blames homeless for damages at MAve Hotel, sues insurer
    As housing price growth plateaus, Shiller warns buyers of “bumpy” ride
    As housing price growth plateaus, Shiller warns buyers of “bumpy” ride
    As housing price growth plateaus, Shiller warns buyers of “bumpy” ride
    RealSure CEO Katie Finnegan (LinkedIn)
    Realogy, Home Partners of America iBuying venture hires first CEO
    Realogy, Home Partners of America iBuying venture hires first CEO
    Leonard Bernstein’s “radical chic” penthouse sells for $24M
    Leonard Bernstein’s “radical chic” penthouse sells for $24M
    Leonard Bernstein’s “radical chic” penthouse sells for $24M
    Zelig Weiss bids for William Vale Hotel after All Year’s demise (William Vale)
    In fight over William Vale hotel, Zelig Weiss offers to buy it
    In fight over William Vale hotel, Zelig Weiss offers to buy it
    Assembly OSM cofounders William and Christopher Sharples with an illustration of the building design (AOSM)
    Modular construction firm founded by SHoP principals unveils first apartment
    Modular construction firm founded by SHoP principals unveils first apartment
    The Centre at Purchase  and George Comfort & Sons CEO Peter Duncan (George Comfort & Sons)
    George Comfort & Sons escapes foreclosure on Westchester office campus
    George Comfort & Sons escapes foreclosure on Westchester office campus
    Basketball star Ben Simmons with the Moorestown property (Compass, Getty)
    Philadelphia 76ers’ fallen star Ben Simmons lists NJ mansion for $5M
    Philadelphia 76ers’ fallen star Ben Simmons lists NJ mansion for $5M
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...