Judge upholds city laws protecting non-paying businesses

Lawsuit sought to overturn laws signed in response to the pandemic

New York /
Dec.December 01, 2020 08:00 AM
 
Judge Ronnie Abrams ruled several laws signed by Mayor Bill de Blasio are constitutional. (Wikipedia Commons, iStock, Getty)

Judge Ronnie Abrams ruled several laws signed by Mayor Bill de Blasio are constitutional. (Wikipedia Commons, iStock, Getty)

A federal judge swept away a legal challenge to a package of bills designed to protect retail tenants during the pandemic.

The lawsuit, filed by two small commercial landlords in July, argued that the City Council’s and Mayor Bill de Blasio’s Covid-19 protections for non-paying businesses deny landlords’ right to free speech and due process, as well as violate the contract clause of the Constitution.

However, United States District Judge Ronnie Abrams of the Southern District of New York disagreed, ruling that the laws are constitutional.

“Plaintiffs have expressed some legitimate concerns, and the Court recognizes the toll the pandemic has taken on them, in addition to their tenants, all New Yorkers, and millions more around the world,” Abrams wrote in her decision. “Nonetheless … the Court cannot conclude that these three challenged laws violate any of Plaintiffs’ constitutional rights.”

The lawsuit challenged several pieces of legislation that were hastily passed in May as a means of protecting residential and commercial tenants who were struggling because of the pandemic.

Two of the laws prohibit landlords from harassing residential or commercial tenants out of a space, such as by changing the locks, if they have been affected by Covid — though the criteria was broadly defined, with essential workers, tenants diagnosed with Covid or those struggling financially all protected. Another law temporarily bars landlords from going after the personal assets of restaurant and store owners who owe rent.

Some City Council members voted against the bills, saying they interfered with private contracts. Concerns were raised upon the bills’ introduction that they were unconstitutional.

In her ruling, Abrams said that because landlords are not prohibited from sending out rent demands, their First Amendment rights are not infringed upon. Additionally, Abrams noted that the law preventing landlords from going after personal assets of store owners and restaurateurs who own rent — known as the guaranty law — is not a contract clause violation because it is “reasonable, necessary, and passed to advance a legitimate public interest.”

Stephen Younger of Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler, the lead attorney for the plaintiffs, said his clients are deciding whether to appeal.

“In our view, these measures are only going to inflict more pain on the city’s economy because it basically shifts losses onto the backs of small landlords who just can’t afford these losses at these hard times,” said Younger.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Before the pandemic, national tenants paid 94 percent of rent. (Getty)

    Retail rent collections rebound to 90%

    Retail rent collections rebound to 90%
    Cindat Capital Management CEO Greg Peng and Hersha Hospitality Trust CEO Jay Shah with 51 Nassau Street (Google Maps)

    7 Manhattan hotels head to auction block

    7 Manhattan hotels head to auction block
    As companies leave Silicon Valley, Austin, Texas is becoming a top destination. (Getty)

    Silicon Valley exodus: Where’d everyone go?

    Silicon Valley exodus: Where’d everyone go?
    TF Cornerstone President Frederick Elghanayan with 2-10 54th Avenue and 55-01 Second Street in Long Island City (Google Maps)

    The 10 biggest new project filings in NYC

    The 10 biggest new project filings in NYC
    Gov. Andrew Cuomo announced that a major development surrounding Penn Station. (Getty)

    Cuomo adds housing to $51B Midtown West project

    Cuomo adds housing to $51B Midtown West project
    Alex Sapir (Getty)

    Former Sapir employee accuses company of retaliation

    Former Sapir employee accuses company of retaliation
    229 West 43rd Street in New York and Two Westlake Park in Texas. New York and Texas are the states with the largest exposure to loans with appraisal reductions. (Photos via iStock; Google Maps; JLL)

    What appraisal reductions mean for future losses on CMBS loans

    What appraisal reductions mean for future losses on CMBS loans
    Cushman & Wakefield CEO Brett White, Mayor Bill de Blasio, and Donald Trump, Eric Trump and Donald Trump Jr. (Getty)

    Cushman & Wakefield, NYC cut ties to Trump Organization

    Cushman & Wakefield, NYC cut ties to Trump Organization
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...