Howard Hughes’ Seaport project dealt major blow

Landmarks Preservation Commission calls proposed towers at 250 Water Street too tall

New York /
Jan.January 14, 2021 09:15 AM

A rendering of 250 Water Street and Howard Hughes Corporation CEO David O'Reilly (SOM; Getty; iStock)

A rendering of 250 Water Street and Howard Hughes Corporation CEO David O’Reilly (SOM; Getty; iStock)


It’s back to the drawing board — or perhaps the garbage bin — for proposed towers at 250 Water Street.

Over the years the Howard Hughes Corporation has faced extensive community pushback for its plans to build two mixed-use towers at the site. And this week, the Landmarks Preservation Commission — dismissing pleas from a slew of influential New Yorkers at a Jan. 5 hearing — said the project was simply too tall.

According to the Tribeca Trib, the commission told the Texas-based developer at a meeting Tuesday that the towers would “invade the district’s sky space.”

The panel took no official action, but made clear it would not approve the project. The setback means Howard Hughes will have to revisit plans for the site with architects Skidmore, Owings & Merrill.

“We appreciate the LPC’s thoughtful feedback and look forward to returning soon to the commission,” a spokesperson for the developer told the newspaper in a statement.

Some have speculated that redevelopment of the giant parking lot would not be economically viable if limited to the historic district’s typical scale of five stories. A low-scale project would certainly not generate enough profit to endow the historic district’s long-struggling South Street Seaport Museum with $50 million, as Howard Hughes’ 40-story towers promised to do.

Howard Hughes bought the site for $180 million in 2018 from the Milstein family. Its current plan, scaled back from an earlier proposal, includes two 470-foot towers with 260 condo units and 100 affordable rental units.

At that height, the towers would be well over the existing 120-foot zoning height limit in the area, the local paper noted. Beyond approval from Landmarks, the developer needs a zoning modification from the City Council; it has support for that lined up from the local member, Margaret Chin.

Critics of the proposal argue that Landmarks can only consider its architecture and scale, not the $50 million that Howard Hughes said the project would allow it to contribute to the Seaport Museum.

The commission’s chair, Sarah Carroll, agreed, saying at Tuesday’s meeting that the benefits for the museum, “while laudable, are not factors that we can consider or rely on in determining whether the proposed designs for the 250 Water Street site” are appropriate.

Commissioners were unswayed by arguments that the site has been undeveloped for decades, has no historic significance, and is at the edge of the historic district with much taller buildings immediately behind it.

[Tribeca Trib] — Sylvia Varnham O’Regan





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Lewis Road Residential Planned Development (Pine Barrens, iStock)
    Big golf, resi project in East Quogue approved
    Big golf, resi project in East Quogue approved
    From left: BSA chairwoman Margery Perlmutter, DRAW Brooklyn founder Alexandros Washburn, New York City Council Member Carlos Menchaca with renderings of the project (Photos via the City of New York, LinkedIn and Arquitectonica)
    How a Red Hook developer circumvented the City Council
    How a Red Hook developer circumvented the City Council
    15 Park Row (Google Maps)
    J&R Music founders sell Park Row apartment tower for $140M
    J&R Music founders sell Park Row apartment tower for $140M
    Claudio Del Vecchio has owned Brooks Brothers since 2001. (Getty)
    Brooks Brothers’ Madison Ave store could give way to Midtown East tower
    Brooks Brothers’ Madison Ave store could give way to Midtown East tower
    (Photo illustration by The Real Deal)
    This office redeveloper is going all in
    This office redeveloper is going all in
    Clare Newman with Governors Island (Credit: Governors Island, Getty Images)
    Governors Island redevelopment opposed as excessive
    Governors Island redevelopment opposed as excessive
    Union Square Park to gain 2 acres in $100M plan (Getty_
    Union Square Park to gain 2 acres in $100M plan
    Union Square Park to gain 2 acres in $100M plan
    Kirk Goodrich, president of Monadnock Development, is opposed to the bill sponsored by Bran Lander. (Getty, Monadnock Development)
    Council bill favoring nonprofits for affordable housing will hurt minority-led firms: developers
    Council bill favoring nonprofits for affordable housing will hurt minority-led firms: developers
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...