Greenwich Village site eyed for shelter has asbestos issues: lawsuit

Tenants claim construction would agitate asbestos and lead paint throughout the building

New York /
May.May 18, 2021 01:30 PM
Project Renewal CEO Eric Rosenbaum, Attorney Adam Leitman Bailey and 27 West 11th Street. (Google Maps, Facebook via Project Renewal, Bailey)

Project Renewal CEO Eric Rosenbaum, Attorney Adam Leitman Bailey and 27 West 11th Street. (Google Maps, Facebook via Project Renewal, Bailey)

A lawsuit filed last week by four tenants of a Greenwich Village apartment building could stall plans to turn it into a shelter for homeless women.

The complaint cites high levels of lead paint and asbestos throughout 27 West 11th Street — toxins that could prove hazardous for the property’s elderly residents once construction begins, according to attorney Adam Leitman Bailey, who is representing the tenants — all of whom live in first- and second-floor single-room occupancy units — in the lawsuit.

The city had proposed overhauling the building as part of the mayor’s “Turning the Tide” initiative to move homeless individuals out of hotels and cluster sites and into 90 new shelters. The Department of Social Services tapped homeless services nonprofit Project Renewal to operate the shelter, and Community Board 2 greenlit the project last summer. The Department of Environmental Protection conducted an asbestos assessment last spring that found no hazardous materials.

In December, Bailey’s clients caught wind of the demolition plans, which call for construction on the first- and second-floors to accommodate 90 additional residents in the 77-unit building.

“It looked like the construction was going to intentionally drive them out of the building,” Bailey said.

The notice specified the project was “not evicting any tenants.” But the four SRO tenants, each of whom is over 60, feared the work would stir up hazardous materials in the building.

Bailey scheduled a second survey of the building — one that included a lead paint check — and found that the city had erred in its assessment.

The city’s report showed samples had been taken of the building’s facade and roof ahead of a work order that would repair the outside walls and replace windows. The interior hadn’t been inspected for asbestos, because it wouldn’t be affected by the work.

Bailey’s survey checked the tenants’ apartments, plus common areas, and found levels that were a “cause of concern for the entire building,” wrote Kenneth Friedman, an inspector with Shaindel Environmental.

“Special mitigation efforts are necessary to perform any demolition, construction or renovation work in the building so as to protect these elderly tenants,” he wrote.

Paint samples showed lead levels above federal and state guidelines. The shelter will be built for women who are not living with children. However, the survey details that a six-year-old boy regularly visits the building with his father.

Landlords must ensure that any peeling paint or surfaces that may have deteriorated are properly remediated, and must follow safety guidelines for construction work in buildings that may have lead-based paint (which is assumed to be any structure built before 1960) or asbestos.

The suit names the Department of Housing Preservation and Development as a respondent and asks that the agency remediate the asbestos and lead issues and put any work on hold until the building is free of hazardous materials. An HPD spokesperson did not provide a comment by the time of publication.

Bailey’s hope is that the clean-up will take enough time that the project seeks out an alternative shelter site.

“Our goal is to get Project Renewal to find another building so my clients can live the rest of their lives in peace,” Bailey said.

Project Renewal is neither a party to the suit, nor the owner of the building; rather, they would operate the shelter once renovations had wrapped. As of last summer, Project Renewal planned on a two-year construction timeline.

A Project Renewal spokesperson said it had no comment on the lawsuit.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    From left: 80 Columbus Circle with Robert Stiller and 737 Park Avenue with Hamad bin Khalifa Al Thani (Photos via Google Maps, Agnovos, State of Qatar, Godsfriendchuck/Wikimedia)
    Mandarin Oriental, 737 Park units sell at substantial losses
    Mandarin Oriental, 737 Park units sell at substantial losses
    Steve Cohen and 151 East 158th Street (Getty, Google Maps)
    Steve Cohen’s $30M condo sells above asking — after a 74% cut
    Steve Cohen’s $30M condo sells above asking — after a 74% cut
    Nicole Oge, Casa Blanca founders Hannah Bomze and Erez Zaurer (Getty, Casa Blanca)
    Former Elliman, WeWork marketing chief joins “Bumble for homes” startup
    Former Elliman, WeWork marketing chief joins “Bumble for homes” startup
    470 Broome Street  and Rayo Withanage (Photos via Saltzman Architects, P.C. and Withanage)
    From Picasso’s estate to squatting in Soho: The 470 Broome Street affair
    From Picasso’s estate to squatting in Soho: The 470 Broome Street affair
    Tenants are singing longer leases to lock in low rent. (Getty)
    Tenants locking in longer leases as apartment rents rise
    Tenants locking in longer leases as apartment rents rise
    Last year more people relocated to ZIP codes with lower home values and more space. (Getty)
    Long-distance movers found cheaper and larger homes in 2020
    Long-distance movers found cheaper and larger homes in 2020
    Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell (Getty)
    Traders eye Fed pullback on mortgage bonds
    Traders eye Fed pullback on mortgage bonds
    (iStock)
    Manhattan contracts bloomed to all-time highs in the spring
    Manhattan contracts bloomed to all-time highs in the spring
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...