Thor Equities can keep $1.2M deposit on failed 933 Broadway sale: judge

The lawsuit stemmed from dispute over a key deadline in now-collapsed transaction

New York /
Sep.September 13, 2021 08:00 AM
Thor Equities’ Joe Sitt and 933 Broadway (Thor)

Thor Equities’ Joe Sitt and 933 Broadway (Thor)

A judge has sided with Thor Equities in a lawsuit involving a failed sale of 933 Broadway, allowing Joe Sitt’s firm to keep the $1.2 million deposit from the would-have-been buyer, Mactaggart Family & Partners.

The lawsuit stemmed from a dispute over how to count days to determine a key deadline in a nearly $24 million now-collapsed transaction in the Flatiron District.

On March 11, 2020, Mactaggart Family & Partners signed a contract to purchase the Thor retail building. But the family office backed out on May 7, asserting that Thor defaulted on the agreement by not providing documentation for all leases held by the building’s tenants by the deadline, defined in the contract as “at least two business days before the closing date.”

The closing date was set for Monday, May 11, and in Mactaggart’s interpretation, the deadline for providing documentation passed at midnight on May 6. The firm sued Thor to get the deposit back.

Thor, however, argued that Mactaggart breached the contract by prematurely exiting on May 7, even though Thor had until midnight of that day to submit all documents. In its counterclaim, Thor asked the judge to dismiss Mactaggart’s lawsuit and to keep the deposit.

Justice Louis Nock, who presided over the lawsuit, agreed with Thor’s interpretation of the deadline, saying May 7 was the last business day “on which [Thor] could timely deliver” the documentation. On top of losing the $1.2 million deposit, Mactaggart is required to cover Thor’s costs for attorneys, according to the judge’s decision. Trial court rulings in state Supreme Court are almost always appealed, so Thor is not in the clear yet.

The dispute likely wouldn’t have happened if not for the pandemic. When the sale contract was signed, 933 Broadway was a thriving retail building with tenants such as Le Pain Quotidien and Godiva Chocolatier. But shortly after the contract signing, the pandemic ravaged the retail industry.

In April 2020, Le Pain was reportedly looking to close some of its stores. Around the same time, Godiva told Thor that it would cease paying rent. Mactaggart argued in court that these changed tenant conditions should have allowed it to terminate the contract even before the deadline, but the judge wasn’t convinced.

Mactaggart and law firms representing Mactaggart and Thor did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Thor declined to comment.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    79 Clifton Place, 80-01 37th Avenue, 45 East Mosholu Parkway North (LoopNet, Google Maps)
    Residential dealmakers storm city’s investment sales market
    Residential dealmakers storm city’s investment sales market
    Brookfield kicks off review process for $2B Stonestown Galleria mall redevelopment
    Brookfield kicks off review process for $2B Stonestown Galleria mall redevelopment
    Brookfield kicks off review process for $2B Stonestown Galleria mall redevelopment
    CRE held up through the pandemic far better than most expected (iStock)
    How commercial real estate survived the pandemic
    How commercial real estate survived the pandemic
    SL Green CEO Marc Holliday and Ashkenazy Aqcuisition’s Ben Ashkenazy and the property (Google Maps, SL Green)
    SL Green snaps up Ashkenazy’s 690 Madison through foreclosure
    SL Green snaps up Ashkenazy’s 690 Madison through foreclosure
    How NYC’s top real estate law firms got creative in an unusual year
    How NYC’s top real estate law firms got creative in an unusual year
    How NYC’s top real estate law firms got creative in an unusual year
    Thor facing pre-foreclosure suit at 470 Broadway, sale of 115 Mercer
    Thor facing pre-foreclosure suit at 470 Broadway, sale of 115 Mercer
    Thor facing pre-foreclosure suit at 470 Broadway, sale of 115 Mercer
    The Closing: Ron Dickerman
    The Closing: Ron Dickerman
    The Closing: Ron Dickerman
    Reuben Bros. bag pair of Madison Avenue retail properties
    Reubens Bros.’ Madison Ave shopping spree tops mid-market deals
    Reubens Bros.’ Madison Ave shopping spree tops mid-market deals
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...