Homeowners declare final victory in fight over Amagansett “Truck Beach”

Appeals court upholds ruling declaring 22-acre stretch private; East Hampton officials hint at pursuing eminent domain

Tri-State /
Sep.September 17, 2021 08:30 AM
(Getty)

“Truck Beach” will need a new name after the courts ruled that it is private. (Getty)

After decades of public use, the fight to keep Long Island’s “Truck Beach” open to visitors may have hit its final roadblock.

The state’s highest court has put to rest the issue of Amagansett’s most contested stretch of sand, denying an attempt by East Hampton Town officials to maintain public access to the 4,000-foot beach.

The Court of Appeals on Tuesday reaffirmed a February decision that the beach belongs to the homeowners who live at its adjacent properties, not the town, Newsday reported. Having a private rather than public beach in front of their houses greatly enhances the value of those properties.

The homeowners sued East Hampton in 2009, claiming the beach — long a popular destination for day visitors and local fisherman who would park their vehicles there — was private property. Their claim was rooted in the town trustees’ 1882 sale of a tract of land, including the beach, to developer Arthur Benson.

A judge sided with the town in 2016, allowing the town to maintain public access, before that ruling was overturned on appeal five years later. Tuesday’s decision means that the approximately 110 nearby homeowners will be responsible for maintaining the 22-acre parcel moving forward, according to Newsday.

Apart from greater privacy and less pickup truck exhaust, of course, the homeowners also stand to see their property values increase immensely due to the ruling.

“It puts this to bed,” attorney Stephen Angel, who represented the homeowners, told the publication. “Our clients own the property.”

East Hampton Town officials disagree. The town has floated the possibility of condemning the property, as a last resort, through eminent domain. At least one town supervisor, Peter Van Scoyoc, supports that move.

“I personally feel it’s incumbent upon us and appropriate to condemn for the public good,” Van Scoyoc told Newsday.

[Newsday] — Dennis Lynch


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Community Development Corporation of Long Island CEO Gwen O'Shea (CDCLI, iStock)
Nassau County aims to salvage $6M rent relief program
Nassau County aims to salvage $6M rent relief program
270 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY (Loopnet)
Legendary Hampton Bays bar up for sale
Legendary Hampton Bays bar up for sale
Dick Cavett and the property in Montauk (Compass, Wikipedia)
Dick Cavett sells estate for $24M in priciest Montauk deal this year
Dick Cavett sells estate for $24M in priciest Montauk deal this year
Just-sold Shelter Island hotel borrows $17M for transformation
Just-sold Shelter Island hotel borrows $17M for transformation
Just-sold Shelter Island hotel borrows $17M for transformation
 The Ocean Surf Resort at 84 S Emerson Avenue and Sands Motel at 71 South Emerson Avenue (Photos via Nest Seekers)
Two Montauk hotels hit the market asking combined $71M
Two Montauk hotels hit the market asking combined $71M
15 Farm Springs Road, Farmington, CT and The Boulevard in Yaphank, LI
(Google Maps, TheBoulevardNY.com)
Connecticut, Long Island projects show how pandemic has changed real estate
Connecticut, Long Island projects show how pandemic has changed real estate
Village of Freeport Mayor Robert Kennedy, and Cleveland Avenue fields (Google Maps, Twitter via 
Robert Kennedy)
Village, school district feud over potential land sale to Amazon
Village, school district feud over potential land sale to Amazon
Gov. Kathy Hochul (Getty, iStock)
Hochul signs bill that could add 0.5% tax to most East End sales
Hochul signs bill that could add 0.5% tax to most East End sales
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...