Given runaround by Oyster Bay, developer sells to storage firm

Paul Laruccia aimed to build senior housing, rental units in Syosset

Tri-State /
Nov.November 22, 2021 08:45 AM
The site where a senior house was proposed (Google Maps, iStock)

The site where senior housing was proposed was bought by a storage company. (Google Maps, iStock)

A Syosset parcel that was to house people will likely hold only their stuff instead.

After failing for five years to get approval from Oyster Bay for a residential project, a developer sold the land to an investment firm specializing in outdoor storage.

Woodbury developer Paul Laruccia sold the 5.7-acre plot at 80 Jericho Turnpike last week, Newsday reported. Simi Capital and Cerberus Capital Management purchased it for just under $15 million, five years after Laruccia paid STP Associates $10.1 million for the land.

The sale ends a frustrating saga for Laruccia, who sought to develop a 61-unit senior housing facility, 44 market-rate rentals and commercial space on the site.

The parcel was formerly the home of a mobile home park. The last residents were evicted in 2016, the same year Laruccia bought the parcel.

Laruccia claims he spent five years planning the development, culminating in a hearing in front of the Oyster Bay Town Board on Jan. 28, 2020, where the developer was seeking a special-use permit and zoning change.

Laruccia told Newsday that in November 2020, his attorney received an informal notification that the project would not happen.

“When we heard that, we figured, ‘You know what, it’s time to move on,’” the developer told Newsday.

A spokesman for the town claimed that the town attorney had questions for Laruccia’s attorney about a reduction in density and height differences between the two planned buildings. Laruccia countered that he already answered many questions and was not aware of any about height or density.

“We accounted for all their comments,” Laruccia said.

Left in limbo is a sandwich shop at the site. The owner of Village Heros, nearing its 50th year in business, expressed hope the new owner would keep the shop. Otherwise, it may have to relocate out of Syosset.

[Newsday] — Holden Walter-Warner





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Clockwise from bottom left: Signature Premier Properties' Peter Morris, Coldwell Banker's Sue Yannaccone, Douglas Elliman's Howard Lorber and Coach Real Estate Associates' Georgianna Finn
    Ranking the brokerages that rule NYC’s suburbs
    Ranking the brokerages that rule NYC’s suburbs
    Fairfield Properties’ Michael Broxmeyer and 405 East Main Street in Bay Shore (LinkedIn, Google Maps)
    Fairfield adds to Long Island portfolio with $60M purchase
    Fairfield adds to Long Island portfolio with $60M purchase
    Victor Sigoura and 109 East 79th Street
    Life after Naftali: Sigoura breaks out with UES project
    Life after Naftali: Sigoura breaks out with UES project
    From left: Extell's Gary Barnett with 217 West 57th Street, Related's Jeff Blau with 450 Washington, 300 West 30th Street and Fortis' Jonathan Landau Olympia Dumbo
    New condos cool in Brooklyn, but hold steady in Manhattan
    New condos cool in Brooklyn, but hold steady in Manhattan
    A photo illustration of Gainesville Mayor Harvey Ward and Gainesville, Florida (Getty, Harvey Ward)
    NIMBYs triumph in Florida upzoning battle
    NIMBYs triumph in Florida upzoning battle
    From left: Adam Weiner and John Fish (Getty, LinkedIn, Curry)
    Developer destroyed potential evidence in battle over $800M project
    Developer destroyed potential evidence in battle over $800M project
    Starwood's Barry Sternlicht with rendering of Field & Stream Lodge
    Sternlicht’s Starwood plans outdoor-focused hotel chain
    Sternlicht’s Starwood plans outdoor-focused hotel chain
    Connecticut proposal would convert empty box stores into housing
    Connecticut proposal would convert empty box stores into housing
    Connecticut proposal would convert empty box stores into housing
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...