California ultra-luxury project halted on wildfire risk

Judge rules mass evacuation must be considered before development moves forward

National Weekend Edition /
Jan.January 08, 2022 12:00 PM

(Lotusland Investment Holdings)

Plans for 1,400 luxury homes in a wildfire hotspot about 90 miles north of San Francisco have been put on hold over concerns about how residents would be evacuated when the next blaze hits.

According to the San Francisco Chronicle, a Lake County Superior Court judge ruled this week that the so-called Guenoc Valley Project can’t move forward until planners figure out what would happen should a mass evacuation sends thousands of residents fleeing down the small country roads that lead to the community.

The development, proposed by Lotusland Investment Group of San Francisco, features the homes along with a golf course, culinary school and five boutique hotels on 25 square miles of rolling hills snuggled between Sonoma and Napa counties — but on land that has been hit by fires four times in the last 10 years, and 11 times since 1952, according to the suit.

Lake County’s Board of Supervisors approved the project two years ago, according to the newspaper, but a lawsuit filed by the Center for Biological Diversity — and later joined by the state attorney general’s office — claimed developers didn’t do enough to address the risk of fire.

Planners did include fire safety measures such as designated areas to flee to, fire cameras, and fire breaks, and the judge’s ruling conceded many risks were dealt with, but the prospect of a mass evacuations was not — and that was enough to hit the pause button.

Critics of the project praised the decision, according to the publication, calling it a step in the right direction when it comes to land management in an area prone to dangerous conditions.

“This has statewide implications,” said Peter Broderick, a staff attorney at the Center for Biological Diversity. “Developers need to start looking at the impact of development to the surrounding communities in fire-prone areas.”

But Lake County officials said that developers had done more than their fair share, including proposing a new fire station and helipad, and that if the ruling ultimately kills the project, it will be a “tremendous loss” to the community.

The project is one of a number being challenged by the state’s attorney general in a crackdown that hopes to reduce California’s wildfire danger. It comes in the aftermath of the devastating fires in Redding, Santa Rosa and other cities that the AG says proves housing sprawl can be additional kindling for wildfires, according to the publication.

“Local governments and developers have a responsibility to take a hard look at projects that exacerbate wildfire risk and endanger our communities,” Attorney General Rob Bonta said in a statement. “We can’t keep making shortsighted land use decisions that will have impacts decades down the line. We must build responsibly.”

[San Francisco Chronicle] — Vince DiMiceli





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    53 Downing Street (Compass)
    Gut-renovated West Village townhouse tops Manhattan’s priciest contracts
    Gut-renovated West Village townhouse tops Manhattan’s priciest contracts
    The Island Farm in San Gregorio (Sotheby’s International Realty)
    564-acre California ranch with redwoods, six homes and two Prohibition-era bars lists for $22.5m
    564-acre California ranch with redwoods, six homes and two Prohibition-era bars lists for $22.5m
    Alex Rodriguez - businessman, philanthropist and former professional baseball player - in front of the Beresford (Getty Images, Wikipedia/David Shankbone, Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
    A-Rod’s $10M co-op deal approved after “tantrum”
    A-Rod’s $10M co-op deal approved after “tantrum”
    A. Bradley Nelson, chief marketing officer, Sotheby's International Realty (Sotheby's International, iStock/Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
    Hybrid work, crypto and inflation poised to stoke 2022 luxury market
    Hybrid work, crypto and inflation poised to stoke 2022 luxury market
    Justin Timberlake - celebrity singer, songwriter, producer and actor - in front of 443 Greenwich (Wikipedia/Gage Skidmore, Compass, iStock/Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
    Justin Timberlake says “Bye Bye Bye” to 443 Greenwich
    Justin Timberlake says “Bye Bye Bye” to 443 Greenwich
    Tribeca condos topped Manhattan’s priciest contracts
    Tribeca condos topped Manhattan’s priciest contracts
    Tribeca condos topped Manhattan’s priciest contracts
    Police patrol a neighborhood decimated by the Marshall Fire on January 4, 2022 in Louisville, Colorado. (Photo by Michael Ciaglo/Getty)
    Report: Insurance won’t cover damage wreaked by Colorado wildfire
    Report: Insurance won’t cover damage wreaked by Colorado wildfire
    Lake Tahoe feels the heat
    Lake Tahoe feels the heat
    Lake Tahoe feels the heat
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...