Landlords get high-tech in housing court

Video surveillance becomes a powerful tool in rent-regulation cases

TRD LOS ANGELES /
Jan.January 12, 2017 09:30 AM

From the New York website: Forget Big Brother. The landlord is watching you.

Landlords are increasingly using video surveillance in housing court cases over rent-regulated apartments, most commonly to investigate tenants who say the valuable unit is their primary residence, but may live elsewhere, the Wall Street Journal reported.

Bradley Silverbush, a senior litigator at Rosenberg & Estis, said he has at least a dozen video investigations under way at any single time. Each camera costs between $5,000 and $10,000 to setup and install, with an additional monthly fee, he said.

Courts have found that building owners have the right to set up security cameras in lobbies and public hallways, just as long as they aren’t focused inside tenants’ apartments, New York University law professor Andrew Scherer said.

In October, a tenant lawyer who removed a surveillance camera from a Lloyd Goldman-owned apartment building in 2015 agreed to pay $700 in restitution.

And in 2015 a young woman living on the Upper West Side filed charges against her landlord after she discovered a hidden camera in her bathroom clock.

Some tenant lawyers argue the cameras are a form of harassment.

“Video surveillance is very intrusive and frequently used to monitor tenant movements,” said attorney Mark Bierman, who represented a pair of defendants in a case the Journal cited. “Tenants should not be subjected to that.”

Bierman’s clients, New York City Police Department veteran Miguel Cruz and his brother Victor, were both indicted and convicted for perjury after video evidence contradicted statements they made in court.

Miguel Cruz testified in court that he visited his brother several times a week at his rent-regulated apartment on West 16th Street in Manhattan, but video recorded in the building in 2014 and 2015 showed the brothers stopping by the apartment over more than 12 months. They never appeared together. [WSJ]Rich Bockmann


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Michael Weinstein (Credit: Charley Gallay/Getty Images)

How 3 ballot measures in November could forever change California real estate

How 3 ballot measures in November could forever change California real estate
Gov. Newsom and Michael Weinstein (Credit: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images, Charley Gallay/Getty Images)

“We anticipate a tsunami of evictions”: Tenant advocates call on Newsom to tighten rent laws

“We anticipate a tsunami of evictions”: Tenant advocates call on Newsom to tighten rent laws
Garcetti bans residential rent increases on rent-controlled units in LA
(Credit:iStockphoto)

Garcetti bans rent hikes for rent-stabilized units

Garcetti bans rent hikes for rent-stabilized units
LA city council members want to close “loophole” in rent control law

LA measure would make it tougher for landlords to force out tenants for renovations

LA measure would make it tougher for landlords to force out tenants for renovations
Michael Weinstein, the director of the AIDS Healthcare Foundation

It’s back: AIDS Healthcare rental cap bill heads to ballot

It’s back: AIDS Healthcare rental cap bill heads to ballot
Art Caption: Clockwise from top left: Assemblyman David Chiu and Gov. Gavin Newsom pushed for a statewide rent control law, L.A. mansions that sold for combined $400+ million, developer Mohamed Hadid battled to save his Bel Air project, Frederik Eklund of Douglas Elliman moved to L.A. and (inset) streaming services gobbled up more space.

LA’s biggest real estate stories of 2019

LA’s biggest real estate stories of 2019
Tenancy in common arrangementsare growing in gentrifying Eastside neighborhoods like Silver Lake, Echo Park and Glassell Park (Credit: iStock)

LA landlords pitch controversial ownership arrangement as rent law kicks in

LA landlords pitch controversial ownership arrangement as rent law kicks in
Assemblyman David Chiu

Landlords are evicting tenants ahead of rent control law: tenant group

Landlords are evicting tenants ahead of rent control law: tenant group
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...