Judge orders LA to reconsider Charles Co.’s District Square project

Planning board can’t reject housing just because it hates gentrification, jurist rules

Los Angeles /
Nov.November 16, 2020 11:00 AM
Rendering of 577-unit District Square project in South L.A. (Los Angeles Department of City Planning, iStock)
Rendering of 577-unit District Square project in South L.A. (Los Angeles Department of City Planning, iStock)

A judge has ordered the city of Los Angeles to reconsider Arman and Mark Gabay’s 577-unit District Square project after determining the city’s rejection of it violated state law.

The brothers sued the city in February after the South L.A. Area Planning Commission declined to approve the Arlington Heights project. California Superior Court Judge James Chalfant said that violated the state’s Housing Affordability Act, according to the L.A. Times.

Chalfant was highly critical of that decision, saying the planning commission “clearly acted in bad faith.” The Housing Affordability Act bars local governments from rejecting residential developments if they comply with zoning and planning rules unless there is a threat to public health or safety, according to the Times.

Chalfant said the board applied “subjective” criteria to the project, which is what the law was meant to prevent.

“That is exactly what the [commission] did by imposing its own views that gentrification is bad … and the need for affordable housing trumps all,” the judge wrote in his opinion. “That is not the law and there can be no legitimate dispute that [the commission] acted knowingly and deliberately to violate the law.”

The South L.A. Area Planning Commission is scheduled to consider the project again on Tuesday.

The Gabay brothers’ Charles Company has been planning District Square for nearly a decade. It has had numerous ups and downs, near-starts and delays. The project was approved by the city in late 2018 but the local planning commission rejected it following an appeal of that approval last year.

At one point last year, the developers were shopping the ground lease on the property.
[LAT] — Dennis Lynch

 

Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
State Senator Scott Weiner is the primary author of Senate Bill 9 (Getty, California Legislative)
Study: California’s “upzoning” bill would not lead to widespread redevelopment
Study: California’s “upzoning” bill would not lead to widespread redevelopment
(Getty / Photo Illustration by The Real Deal)
Couple fined $18k for bulldozing recently protected Joshua Trees
Couple fined $18k for bulldozing recently protected Joshua Trees
Rendering of the project (NMDA for CIM Group)
CIM drops residential units at proposed West Hollywood hotel
CIM drops residential units at proposed West Hollywood hotel
Downtown Burbank's Transit Oriented Development Specific Plan (Photo via Downtown Burbank TOD/City of Burbank)
Burbank’s downtown specific plan could add thousands of units of housing around its Metrolink station
Burbank’s downtown specific plan could add thousands of units of housing around its Metrolink station
A rendering of the project with East End Capital managing principals Jonathon Yormak and David Peretz. (Relativity Architects, East End Capital)
East End Capital to convert cold storage into movie studio
East End Capital to convert cold storage into movie studio
(Proper Hotel, Google Maps)
Downtown LA’s Proper Hotel to open in July after years of delays
Downtown LA’s Proper Hotel to open in July after years of delays
J.H. Snyder partner Lon Snyder with One Museum Square. (J. H. Snyder, One Museum Square)
JH Snyder lands $172M loan on new luxury rental tower
JH Snyder lands $172M loan on new luxury rental tower
Councilman John Lee and 10243 N. Topanga Canyon Boulevard (Facebook/CouncilmemberJohnLee, Google Maps)
Housing project for homeless vets gets pushback
Housing project for homeless vets gets pushback
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...