State could require union labor on all affordable housing projects

Critics say proposed legislation would hike costs in already expensive development environment

Los Angeles /
Jun.June 18, 2021 10:00 AM
The State Building and Construction Trades Council president Robbie Hunter (CA Building Trades, iStock)
The State Building and Construction Trades Council president Robbie Hunter (CA Building Trades, iStock)

The state legislature is considering measures that would require developers hire union labor on affordable housing projects. Not surprisingly, the industry is not happy.

Affordable housing developers have criticized the proposal, arguing it would hike costs to build desperately needed affordable units in an already expensive development environment, according to Bloomberg.

Supply costs have been steadily rising, along with home sale prices in Southern California. Cities like Los Angeles, however, support affordable housing projects in the form of bond financing and programs that boost apartment count in exchange for setting aside a portion of units as affordable.

The provisions now being considered would mandate developers hire through union-run apprentice programs; the state currently only requires such hiring for large government projects.

The State Building and Construction Trades Council pushed to include the measures in several bills making their way through the state legislature, according to the report. The union’s president, Robbie Hunter, said the requirement will give workers “another layer of safety,” adding that unionized laborers are less likely “to stay silent if they’re being cheated.”

But opponents say the move would be devastating.

Larry Florin, president and CEO of Sonoma County nonprofit Burbank Housing, said the program “has a potential implication for causing major disruption” to affordable housing production.

“There’s just not enough construction workers to fill the need out there,” he said.

Other critics have said the state already requires a prevailing wage for construction workers.

L.A. County alone is short 500,000 affordable rental homes, according to the California Housing Partnership.

Affordable developers — along with market-rate builders — have long criticized the expensive bureaucratic development process. Longer development timetables run up costs and make some affordable projects impossible.

The state has attempted to speed up the approvals process with a streamlined environmental review program.

[Bloomberg] — Dennis Lynch





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    (Illustration by The Real Deal with Getty)
    In Pasadena, houses of worship can build affordable housing
    In Pasadena, houses of worship can build affordable housing
    Mike Sullivan and rendering for 6000 W. Hollywood Blvd (The Sullivan Family, Getty Images)
    Toyota of Hollywood could turn into a retail village
    Toyota of Hollywood could turn into a retail village
    Oak Road 's David Aghaei with 5600 block of S. Broadway
    Affordable housing developer plans 38-unit building in South LA
    Affordable housing developer plans 38-unit building in South LA
    Brasa Capital Management's Eric Samek and rendering of 3450 W. 43rd Street in Los Angeles (Brasa Capital, HBA)
    Streamline Moderne apartment house coming to Leimert Park
    Streamline Moderne apartment house coming to Leimert Park
    From left: Gavin Newsom and California State Representative Buffy Wicks (Photo Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal with Getty Images)
    California Legislature Passes 4 Housing Bills
    California Legislature Passes 4 Housing Bills
    View of Sylmar Village at 12534 San Fernando Road (JZA)
    Sylmar project aims for 100% affordable market
    Sylmar project aims for 100% affordable market
    Jamison Properties' Jaime Lee and rendering of 3000 Wilshire Boulevard, Koreatown (Jamison Services, USC Lusk, Getty)
    Jamison to raze building for 188 apartments in Koreatown
    Jamison to raze building for 188 apartments in Koreatown
    Avanath's Daryl Carter with Baldwin Village Apartments (LinkedIn)
    Avanath and public agency pay $220M for Baldwin Village apartments
    Avanath and public agency pay $220M for Baldwin Village apartments
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...