Supreme court justice’s home could be affected by Florida beachfront property rights case

Dec.December 08, 2009 05:34 PM

Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens promptly announced his recusal in the Florida beachfront property rights case last Wednesday, after reports surfaced that he owns a home in Fort Lauderdale that would be affected by its outcome. The case, Stop the Beach Renourishment Inc. v. Florida Department of Environmental Protection, asked whether a state program aimed at restoring eroded beaches
resulted in an unconstitutional takeover of beachfront land from
property owners. The homeowners claimed the program diminished the
value of their properties by turning beachfront houses into mere “beach
view” properties. Stevens’ recusal came after public documents were
sent to the Cato Institute, revealing that Stevens’ condominium
property is within a renourishment zone similar to the properties at
issue in the case, and was a surprise to many, given that Stevens had
already participated in earlier stages of the case. This is the second
case Stevens has recused himself from due to property he owns. Ten
years ago, Stevens did not participate in a case which examined the
“right to farm” statute in Iowa, where he owned a 200-acre farm.
[National Law Journal]

Related Articles

Bob Gordon with 2401 Solar Plaza Drive (Credit: Redfin)

Political power couple sells Fort Lauderdale home

Kevin R. Kreutzfeld of Premier Estate Properties and 1408 West Lake Drive

Waterfront home in Fort Lauderdale’s Harbor Beach sells for $11M

22 Isla Bahia Drive and Steven Romaniello

Harbor Beach home sells for $8 million

Niki Higgins of Douglas Elliman and 220 North Compass Drive (Credit: Douglas Elliman and Trulia)

Fort Lauderdale mansion with stock trading room sells for $12M

Renderings of the penthouse and Fredrik Eklund (Credit: Four Seasons Private Residences Fort Lauderdale)

Fredrik Eklund tapped to list $35M PH in Fort Lauderdale

Alan Hooper and 516 Northwest 1st Avenue (Credit: Google Maps)

FATVillage developer buys missing piece for mixed-use project

Bridge Development Partners partner Southeast Region Kevin Carroll and 3233-3303 Southwest 12th Avenue Fort Lauderdale

Bridge Development sells Fort Lauderdale warehouses for $28M

2300 Aqua Vista Boulevard (Credit: Realtor)

Crane mogul drops $12M on waterfront Fort Lauderdale mansion