U.S. Supreme Court ruling on property rights a major win for real estate developers

Orange County home owner claimed denial of land use permit was unconstitutional

TRD MIAMI /
Jun.June 26, 2013 01:00 PM

From the New York site: The U.S. Supreme Court today ruled in favor of a Florida landowner in a case that could have widespread ramifications for property developers challenging state and municipal land use policies, Atlantic Cities reported.

The 11-year-old case was filed by Coy Koontz, the now-deceased, longtime owner of a 15-acre wetlands plot outside Orlando.

In the 1990s, Koontz applied for a permit from the local water management district to develop a building, parking lot and retention pond on almost four acres of the property. Koontz’s son, also named Coy, is now the property owner.

Under Florida law, developers seeking to build on wetlands must get a special permit, and the agencies that issue them can require landowners to offset environmental impacts. Though Koontz floated a plan to conserve the remaining acres, the district wanted him to go further and develop only a single acre or pay workers to improve nearby public wetlands instead.

Instead, Koontz sued, claiming the rejection of the permit amounted to a violation of a Fifth Amendment clause banning the government from taking private property without proper compensation.

The 5-4 majority in Koontz v. St. Johns River Water Management District sided with the developer, seemingly expanding the definition of the so-called Takings Clause.

“It makes no difference that no property was actually taken in this case,” Justice Samuel Alito, writing for the majority, said in the decision. “Extortionate demands for property in the land-use permitting context run afoul of the Takings Clause not because they take property but because they impermissibly burden the right not to have property taken without just compensation.” [Atlantic Cities]Zachary Kussin


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Two Downtown Miami lots sell for $80M after years of litigation

Two Downtown Miami lots sell for $80M after years of litigation

Two Downtown Miami lots sell for $80M after years of litigation
Placeholder image

A high court reprieve for real estate transaction fees

A high court reprieve for real estate transaction fees
U.S. Supreme Court to rule on illegal mortgage fees

U.S. Supreme Court to rule on illegal mortgage fees

U.S. Supreme Court to rule on illegal mortgage fees
Placeholder image

Conrad Black keeps control of PB home

Conrad Black keeps control of PB home
NAI/Merin Hunter Codman Chairman Neil Merin and Golden Bear Plaza

Golden Bear Plaza office complex in Palm Beach Gardens sells at sharp discount

Golden Bear Plaza office complex in Palm Beach Gardens sells at sharp discount
Ivan Chorney and Michael Martirena

Movers & Shakers: Top One Sotheby’s team joins Compass, shakeup at CBRE & more

Movers & Shakers: Top One Sotheby’s team joins Compass, shakeup at CBRE & more
Steve Schonfeld, Bellaria condominium complex (Credit: Google Maps)

Hedge funder Steven Schonfeld sells Palm Beach condo

Hedge funder Steven Schonfeld sells Palm Beach condo
 Javier Cervera Sr.

Javier Cervera Sr., who helped his wife form Miami brokerage after fleeing Cuba, dies

Javier Cervera Sr., who helped his wife form Miami brokerage after fleeing Cuba, dies
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...