Lawsuit accuses Lehman Properties of posting “No felonies” rental ad

HUD issued guidance in 2016 saying landlords could be breaking the law if they refuse to rent to people with criminal records

Miami /
Apr.April 08, 2019 02:30 PM

Fort Lauderdale (Credit: iStock)

A new lawsuit accuses Lehman Properties of posting an ad for apartments in Broward County that said “No felonies.”

The lawsuit was filed last week in Fort Lauderdale district court by “fair housing tester” Delroy Chambers, who is represented by the Dunedin, Florida-based law firm Social Justice Law Collective.

According to the lawsuit, Chambers, who is black, was angered by the ad for the undisclosed property.

“As a black person who has been the subject of discrimination throughout his life, Mr. Chambers is particularly sensitive to discriminatory practices,” the lawsuit states. “Mr. Chambers was insulted and emotionally distressed by being denied housing based on the Defendant’s blanket prohibition.”

Joseph Lehman, owner of Miami-based Lehman Properties, said he was not aware of the ad and would not have approved it. He said the company hadn’t been officially served with the suit.
“I’m not aware of us not allowing people with any background issue. We do try to keep our company safe,” Lehman said, adding that some residents currently living at the company’s properties have felonies and criminal backgrounds.
“But we do have a standard protocol that if you have a vigorous record of homicide, murder or rape, we would typically deny that person,” Lehman said. “My first priority is to keep my staff safe and our best interest of our tenants.”

The suit says the ad made it clear that “rental of the home is subject to a blanket prohibition regarding an applicant’s felony criminal history, which is unlawful under the Fair Housing Act, as it has a disparate impact on Black people, and fails to serve a substantial, legitimate, nondiscriminatory interest.”

The suit said Chambers posed as a potential renter responding to the ad, but was told the apartment was no longer available and was directed to another unit. He asked an employee if having a felony would be an immediate bar to renting the property and was told yes, it would, according to the suit.

The suit seeks a permanent injunction against discrimination based on race, an unspecified money damage award and attorney’s costs and fees.

The Housing and Urban Development Administration issued guidance in 2016 saying landlords could be breaking the law if they refuse to rent to people with criminal records because such a policy would likely have a disproportionate impact on African-American and Hispanic applicants.

Lehman is the owner of several multifamily projects in Miami-Dade, including including a 112-unit property at 611 Northwest 177 Street.

Chambers has filed similar lawsuits in Central Florida. He filed another housing discrimination lawsuit in St. Lucie County in January against the Villages of Lake Lucie Homeowners’ Association, accusing it of running an ad that said: “If you have any felonies at all they will not approve your application so please don’t waste our time.” According to court records, that case was settled quickly.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
GL Homes' Dick Norwalk and Miami-Dade County Mayor Daniella Levine Cava (GL Homes, Miami-Dade, Third District Court of Appeals)
Court ruling throws wrench in GL Homes’ Calusa project
Court ruling throws wrench in GL Homes’ Calusa project
Grant Cardone and Related's Stephen Ross (Getty; Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
Grant Cardone sues Hard Rock Stadium, F1 over stolen $750K watch
Grant Cardone sues Hard Rock Stadium, F1 over stolen $750K watch
Amir Korangy, Michael Shvo and Jeff Greene
Michael Shvo and Jeff Greene talk distress, opportunities in office
Michael Shvo and Jeff Greene talk distress, opportunities in office
Joe and Avi Nakash and the Hotel Breakwater at 940 Ocean Drive (Google Maps, Getty Maps)
Nakash family hit with $17M judgment tied to South Beach hotel
Nakash family hit with $17M judgment tied to South Beach hotel
Trump Group's Jules Trump and Suffolk Construction's John Fish with the Estates at Acqualina (Getty, Suffolk Construction, Google Maps)
Suffolk again sues Estates at Acqualina developer in alleged “Halloween ambush”
Suffolk again sues Estates at Acqualina developer in alleged “Halloween ambush”
From left: Craig Robins and Ugo Colombo
Ugo Colombo, Craig Robins reach settlement in feud over private jet
Ugo Colombo, Craig Robins reach settlement in feud over private jet
A photo illustration of Don Peebles along with 5959 Collins Avenue (left) and 5937 Collins Avenue Avenue (right) (Getty, Google Maps)
Peebles affiliate must pay $1M in sanctions over Bath Club dispute
Peebles affiliate must pay $1M in sanctions over Bath Club dispute
CMC Group’s Ugo Colombo with rendering of Vita at Grove Isle (Vita at Grove Isle, Getty)
Homeowners drop lawsuit over Ugo Colombo Grove Isle project approvals
Homeowners drop lawsuit over Ugo Colombo Grove Isle project approvals
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...