Judge bars Miami Beach from turning off water at properties owing short-term rental fines

The owner of the house at the center of the conflict is challenging city's short-term rental prohibition

Apr.April 16, 2019 08:45 AM

Ralph Serrano, managing director Safe Harbor Equity with the home at 3098 Alton Road in Miami Beach (Credit: Google Maps)

The water will keep flowing in a single-family home in Miami Beach at the center of the city’s crackdown on short-term rentals.

Following an evidentiary hearing earlier this month, Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Jennifer Bailey upheld an earlier ruling that Miami Beach cannot shut water off at 3098 Alton Road because its owner owes $201,500 in illegal short-term rental fines.

During the hearing, Miami Beach financial analyst Jim McMillion testified that the city had never issued disconnection orders for properties that owed money not tied to unpaid water services, until he received an email last year from the building director to shut off five properties owned by individuals and entities that had not paid fines for operating illegal short-term rentals.

In the case of 3098 Alton Road, the city had revoked the single-family home’s certificate of occupancy in early 2018 following a code enforcement investigation that revealed a tenant was subleasing the property on Airbnb.

The owner, 3098 Alton Road LLC, sued the city in November, challenging Miami Beach’s illegal short-term rental ordinance and its exorbitant fines as unconstitutional. The entity, which is owned by Safe Harbor Equity, also sought to force the city to turn the water back on, which Bailey granted on Dec. 3, 2018. The property’s certificate of occupancy and its utilities have since been reinstated.

However, Miami Beach attorneys, in an attempt to convince the judge to reverse her order, requested the evidentiary hearing to show the city had the legal authority to turn the water off because of 3098’s unpaid fines.

Ralph Serrano, managing director of Safe Harbor Equity, told The Real Deal that Bailey recognized the city “grossly overstepped its authority by using strong-arm tactics that overreached and are outside the law.”

“Still, this attempt by the city of Miami Beach to collect on an outrageous $200,000 fine over short-term rentals that a since-evicted tenant was responsible for, should give us all pause,” Serrano said. “Ultimately, this is a victory not just for me, but for the little guy who might not have the resources to take on costly and time-consuming litigation against a giant like a municipality.”

Chris Spuches, 3098’s lawyer, said the city’s legal team argued that Miami Beach had a long-standing policy of shutting off utilities at homes that are in arrears or have liens for violations that are not related to a homeowner’s water bill. The finance department is responsible for issuing the disconnection orders to the public works department, according to McMillon’s testimony.

But he also said that he had never received any memos or direct orders to shut off the water if a property owner didn’t pay short-term rental fines. He said he flagged 3098 Alton Road for disconnection based on a January 2018 email from Miami Beach’s building official.

“The city just plowed forward with a flawed theory until it blew up in their face,” Spuches said.

Miami Beach Chief Deputy City Attorney Aleksandr Boksner told TRD that Miami Beach will appeal Bailey’s ruling. Boksner said the water was shut off because the city’s building official had revoked 3098’s certificate of occupancy, but he did not comment on McMillion’s contradictory statements.

“The city was legally justified in discontinuing water services to the property,” Boksner said. “The city considers the lawsuit to be a senseless maneuver by the plaintiff, which was merely initiated to divert attention from the plaintiff’s illegal hotel operations.”

According to a Feb. 1 memo from Miami Beach City Manager Jimmy Morales, Miami Beach has issued 431 violations totaling $13.3 million in fines. The city dismissed 89 violations worth $4.1 million and and another 40 were closed with property owners agreeing to pay Miami Beach a fraction of the fines. The memo notes the 40 violations were for a total of $1.3 million that were settled for a total of $300,500. The city has also collected $463,500 from owners who did not contest the violations. The remaining $7.8 million remains outstanding.

Related Articles

Lake that Lake Sana Developments wants to partially fill

Northwest Dade property owner seeking to fill lake gets denied — again

55 Palm Avenue (Credit: Realtor and iStock)

Metals executive mines Miami Beach home

Daily Digest Miami

Moishe Mana sells Hibiscus Island home for $12M, CitizenM scores $48M loan to build Brickell hotel

2021-2035 Meridian Avenue, Rani Hussami and Colin Rockson

AquaBlue Group owner lists South Beach apartments for $14M

Moishe Mana and a rendering of 420 South Hibiscus Drive (Credit: Getty Images and iStock)

Moishe Mana sells Hibiscus Island home for $12M

From left: Andrea and Renzo Rosso

Diesel family dishes on Wynwood condo project

100 La Gorce Drive, Carolyn Aronson and Jeff Aronson

Cash4Gold founder drops $20M on Miami Beach estate

Len Blavatnik, 3425 Collins Avenue and Vlad Doronin (Credit: Google Maps, Getty, Wikipedia Commons)

Len Blavatnik teams with Vlad Doronin on Aman-branded towers in Faena District