Saks Fifth Avenue countersues Bal Harbour Shops for defamation

Luxury retailer accuses mall and Matthew Whitman Lazenby of publicizing confidential information to coerce the department store into making alleged missed rent payments

Miami /
Sep.September 03, 2020 04:30 PM
Matthew Whitman Lazenby, Saks Fifth Avenue at Bal Harbour Shops (Credit: Sonya Revell)

Matthew Whitman Lazenby, Saks Fifth Avenue at Bal Harbour Shops (Credit: Sonya Revell)

UPDATED, Sept. 4, 10:25 a.m.: Saks Fifth Avenue is striking back at Bal Harbour Shops for attempting to evict the luxury retailer over alleged missed rent payments.

On Tuesday, the department store chain countersued Bal Harbour Shops and Matthew Whitman Lazenby, president and CEO of Bal Harbour Shops’ owner Whitman Family Development, for defamation, breach of contract and breach of fiduciary duty. The suit was filed in Miami-Dade Circuit Court.

According to the complaint, Saks alleges Bal Harbour Shops and Lazenby disclosed confidential business information to the press as part of an effort to coerce the retail company into making rent payments that were in dispute.

“The defendants initiated a malicious public smear campaign designed for no purpose other than to exact revenge on a tenant who justifiably stood up to the unjustified demands of an unreasonable landlord,” the lawsuit states.

After publication, Lazenby said in an emailed statement that Saks’ lawsuit has no merit.  “We have reviewed Saks Fifth Avenue’s complaint alleging breach of contract and business defamation filed yesterday against Bal Harbour Shops and find it to be without any legal basis,” Lazenby’s statement said. “We intend to vigorously defend this litigation while pursuing all remedies to enforce Saks’ lease obligations and we look forward to these issues being adjudicated by the courts.”

Last month, Bal Harbour Shops sued to evict Saks Fifth Avenue, alleging the luxury shopping center’s anchor tenant since 1974 had failed to pay more than $1.8 million in rent derived from the department store’s net sales. Whitman Family Development is also seeking a partial refund of an $18 million advance the mall provided Saks to renovate the department store amid a $500 million expansion of Bal Harbour Shops, which is at 9700 Collins Avenue in Bal Harbour.

Saks contends its lease agreement contains a clause allowing the company to be excused from its obligations when the store has to close because of an Act of God and government lockdowns. Bal Harbour Shops, including Saks, was forced to close in March along with other non-essential businesses under Miami-Dade and Bal Harbour emergency orders to slow the spread of coronavirus. The shopping center reopened in May.

Ian Putnam, president and CEO of HBC Properties and Investments, the real estate operating entity for Saks’ parent Hudson Bay Company, said in a statement that the department store has been working with its landlords across North America “to amicably and logically share the burden of losses stemming from the ongoing global pandemic.”

“We are disappointed that Mr. Lazenby chose to breach our long-standing agreement and disparage Saks Fifth Avenue, an iconic luxury retailer that has been vital to Bal Harbour’s success for 45 years,” Putnam said. “Unlike others, this landlord has resorted to providing denigrating statements and confidential information to the media for the sole purpose of coercing Saks into settling a disagreement.”

As a result, Saks has been forced to “grapple with the damage to its business and reputation among customers, associates and partners,” Putnam added.

Saks’ lawsuit states the department store’s cash flow stopped when the governmental closures went into effect and many of its employees had to be furloughed. Saks and Bal Harbour Shops disagree over the impact the pandemic had on the department store and the amounts owed under the lease agreement, the complaint states.

Saks accuses Lazenby of sharing confidential information about the department store’s net sales to the press in order to increase pressure on the retail company to resolve the dispute on terms favorable to Bal Harbour Shops.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Matthew Whitman Lazenby and Bal Harbour Shops
Special election could pave way for height increase at Bal Harbour Shops
Special election could pave way for height increase at Bal Harbour Shops
Thor Chairman Joe Sitt, Stefano Ricci CEO Niccolo Ricci and the Miami store. (Getty, Thor, Miami Design District)
Thor Equities sued over alleged unpaid loan on Stefano Ricci Miami Design District store
Thor Equities sued over alleged unpaid loan on Stefano Ricci Miami Design District store
Gil Dezer and renderings of the project (Renderings via Zyscovich Architects)
Neighbors sue to overturn approval of Dezer’s mega project in North Miami Beach
Neighbors sue to overturn approval of Dezer’s mega project in North Miami Beach
Matthew Whitman Lazenby, Grant Cardone, Phil Collins, Orianne Bates, Russell Galbut, Natalie Brabner, Craig Studnicky and Masoud Shojaee (Lazenby by Sonya Revell; Getty, iStock)
South Florida’s juiciest real estate lawsuits of 2020
South Florida’s juiciest real estate lawsuits of 2020
Jeffrey Soffer and Turnberry Isle Yacht and Racquet Club
Turnberry Isle condo association sues Jeffrey Soffer affiliate over lobby repairs
Turnberry Isle condo association sues Jeffrey Soffer affiliate over lobby repairs
An Altmed Müv dispensary in Apollo Beach (Altmed, iStock)
Miami Beach faces new legal challenges over medical marijuana restrictions
Miami Beach faces new legal challenges over medical marijuana restrictions
901 Euclid Avenue (Google Maps)
Short-term rental investor sues Miami Beach, seeks class action
Short-term rental investor sues Miami Beach, seeks class action
Masoud Shojaee with rendering of Sanctuary at Doral and pictured with daughter Lilibet Shojaee (Shoma Group)
Trusts benefitting Masoud Shojaee’s daughters sue to access his company’s financial records
Trusts benefitting Masoud Shojaee’s daughters sue to access his company’s financial records
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...