A-Rod, ex-brother-in-law skip trial, settle dispute over multifamily empire

Agreement comes after the former Yankee shook off civil racketeering, theft claims

Miami /
Nov.November 15, 2021 06:15 PM

From left: Alex Rodriguez, former professional baseball player, and Constantine Scurtis, chief executive officer, Lynd Acquisition Group (Getty Images, Lynd Acquisitiion Group, iStock, Photo Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)

Former baseball slugger Alexander Rodriguez and his ex-brother-in-law, Constantine Scurtis, settled their remaining claims in their seven-year dispute over a once-burgeoning real estate empire, avoiding a trial that was set to begin on Monday.

Scurtis, whose sister Cynthia Scurtis was married to Rodriguez, had sued A-Rod, claiming he had cut him out of their multifamily venture and earnings, according to his complaint. The properties spanned 5,000 units purchased for $300 million in the early 2000s in Florida, Texas, Mississippi, Indiana and Oklahoma.

The former Yankee responded in court that Scurtis had dipped into the partnership’s coffers to the tune of $1.4 million, and then sued Rodriguez as an extortion tactic and to wiggle out of repaying the money Scurtis owed, according to Rodriguez’s counterclaim.

Rodriguez’s attorney said the settlement, reached on Sunday, came after the court shot down Scurtis experts from testifying in court, and significantly cut down the testimony of another. This reduced the claim amount Scurtis could bring to trial, attorney Ben Brodsky said.

Terms of the settlement are confidential, with Brodsky only saying he and Rodriguez “are pleased with it.” Scurtis’ attorney declined comment.

The settlement came on the heels of Rodriguez scoring several major victories in the case.

In November, Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Michael Hanzman shot down Scurtis’ racketeering and theft counts, both civil claims, against Rodriguez. They were among the heftiest in the 59-count suit, as they could have exposed Rodriguez to triple of any damages Scurtis would win.

That decision came after Hanzman in September shot down 13 lawsuits Scurtis had filed this year against Rodriguez. They were separate from Scurtis’ main 2014 complaint, but related to the real estate venture.

Rodriguez was married to Cynthia Scurtis from 2002 to 2008, and his venture with Constantine Scurtis allegedly went awry when the marriage ended. Scurtis claimed he was pushed out as general partner of the limited liability companies the duo had used to own the properties. But Hanzman, in his November order, ruled that Scurtis had off on the transfer of control.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Michael Huffington and the condo building (Getty, Eighty Seven Park)
    Michael Huffington sells Eighty Seven Park condo for $11M a year after purchase
    Michael Huffington sells Eighty Seven Park condo for $11M a year after purchase
    Ivanhoé Cambridge's Nathalie Palladitcheff and Greystar's Bob Faith with the InTown Apartments at 1900 Southwest 8th Street, Miami (Ivanhoé Cambridge, Greystar, InTown Apts.)
    Ivanhoé Cambridge picks up Little Havana apartment complex for $105M
    Ivanhoé Cambridge picks up Little Havana apartment complex for $105M
    AMLI Residential Chairman and CEO Gregory Mutz with the site (Google Maps, AMLI)
    AMLI Residential bets $31M on another Midtown Miami development site
    AMLI Residential bets $31M on another Midtown Miami development site
    South Florida single-family home sales fall in October amid declining inventory
    South Florida single-family home sales fall in October amid declining inventory
    South Florida single-family home sales fall in October amid declining inventory
    Palazzo Della Luna
    $10M Fisher Island closing tops weekly condo sales in Miami-Dade
    $10M Fisher Island closing tops weekly condo sales in Miami-Dade
    13900 Northeast Third Court and 18905 Northeast 25th Avenue (Google Maps)
    Claridge House, Regents Park at Aventura nursing homes trade for $33M
    Claridge House, Regents Park at Aventura nursing homes trade for $33M
    The Oakwood Apartments at 2425 Second Avenue North in Lake Worth Beach (Google Maps)
    New Jersey firm buys Oakwood Apartments in Lake Worth Beach for $35M
    New Jersey firm buys Oakwood Apartments in Lake Worth Beach for $35M
    Lease roundup: Plum Market to open in Aventura, Sprouts in Boca Raton, Best Buy in Dania Beach
    Lease roundup: Plum Market to open in Aventura, Sprouts in Boca Raton, Best Buy in Dania Beach
    Lease roundup: Plum Market to open in Aventura, Sprouts in Boca Raton, Best Buy in Dania Beach
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...