Court ruling allows Jason Halpern to develop Miami Beach resi project

Investor Dhruv Piplani filed the suit in 2017, alleging breach of contract, fiduciary duty

Miami /
Apr.April 12, 2022 06:00 PM

Jason Halpern a rendering of his Indian Creek project (JMH Development)

UPDATED, April 13, 10:15 a.m.: A New York judge dismissed a lawsuit filed by an investor in two of developer Jason Halpern’s Miami Beach properties, allowing his JMH Development to move forward with plans for a condo project on one of the sites.

Investor Dhruv Piplani’s PSB Indian Creek and affiliated entities filed the suit against Halpern, his JMH Indian Creek Development LLC and other companies in 2017. Piplani, who sued over alleged breach of contract and breach of fiduciary duty, sought at least $10 million in damages from the New York developer. PSB’s other partners included Aviv Siso and Louis Buckworth.

The ruling, issued last week, also calls for Piplani’s entity to pay for JMH’s legal fees, according to Herrick, the law firm that represented Halpern and his company. Piplani’s attorneys did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

In the original complaint, Piplani’s entity alleged that Halpern cut it out of a “sweetheart” sale of the development site at 2901 and 2911 Indian Creek Drive for close to $7.8 million in 2017. The buyer was 29 ICD, a company led by Gerard Longo, a long-time business colleague of Halpern. Halpern, who is a managing member of 29 ICD, now plans to develop the property.

Indian Creek Drive runs parallel to Collins Avenue in Miami Beach, and the site is near the Miami Beach EDITION hotel and condo building, as well as near the Faena District.

Piplani’s entity also alleged that Halpern “failed to fulfill his managerial and financial obligations” with the Three Hundred Collins project, a 19-unit condo at 300 Collins Avenue in Miami Beach that was completed in 2018. The Piplani-led entity alleged that Halpern violated their operating agreement by demanding more capital while “refusing to pay mandated distributions and fees” to Piplani.

In a separate lawsuit filed in Miami-Dade County Circuit Court, Halpern’s company was ordered in 2018 to turn over its remaining interest in Three Hundred Collins to Piplani’s PSB Collins. In 2020, the condo association sued the developer, alleging buyers were duped into purchasing units that were not as luxurious as advertised in marketing materials.

Andrea Masley, a judge for the Supreme Court 1st Judicial District in New York, ruled in favor of Halpern last week. In her order, Masley wrote that JMH did not breach the operating agreement it had with Piplani’s entity. Halpern’s entity was able to sell the Indian Creek property without Piplani’s entity because Piplani’s entity breached its contract first by failing to make a mandatory contribution by a due date of March 14, 2016. Piplani’s PSB also failed to fund the July 15, 2016 capital call for $4.1 million.

“JMH concedes that it did not obtain PSB’s consent to sell the property to 29 ICD in January 2017 because consent was not required,” the judge wrote. The sale occurred 10 months after PSB lost its governance rights and three months after its stake was fully diluted, the judge’s ruling states.

“We had unwavering confidence in this project and that the PSB allegations were false,” Halpern said in a statement provided to The Real Deal.

Halpern declined to comment further on his plans, but last year, 29 ICD, the Halpern-controlled entity that now owns the Indian Creek development site, received approval for a six-story, 15-unit residential building with a rooftop deck and mechanical parking system that would be built next to two connecting townhomes.




    An earlier version of this story stated the incorrect number of units planned for the Indian Creek Drive development site. 


    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Ilya Karpov with 3026 North Bay Road
    Russian mogul Ilya Karpov buys waterfront North Bay Road home for $14M
    Russian mogul Ilya Karpov buys waterfront North Bay Road home for $14M
    Long Light Capital's Justin Korsant with 45 East Dilido Drive (Getty, Mike Ruiz)
    Third time’s the charm: Waterfront Venetian Islands home flips for record $4,900 psf
    Third time’s the charm: Waterfront Venetian Islands home flips for record $4,900 psf
    The Oceana in Key Biscayne (Condo.com, iStock)
    Oceana Key Biscayne closing tops Miami-Dade’s weekly condo sales
    Oceana Key Biscayne closing tops Miami-Dade’s weekly condo sales
    Russell Galbut in front of 1030-1050 Sixth Street in Miami Beach (LoopNet, GFO Investments)
    Russell Galbut buys dev site near Five Park in South Beach, plans hotel
    Russell Galbut buys dev site near Five Park in South Beach, plans hotel
    José Isaac Peres with 57 Ocean penthouse (Multiplan Real Estate Asset Management, 57 Ocean, iStock)
    Brazilian billionaire developer’s 57 Ocean PH sells for record $37M
    Brazilian billionaire developer’s 57 Ocean PH sells for record $37M
    A photo illustration of 18 La Gorce Circle (top) and 2000 South Ocean Boulevard (bottom) (Redfin, Realtor.com, Master Brokers Forum, iStock)
    South Florida by the numbers: Local mega listings and sales
    South Florida by the numbers: Local mega listings and sales
    Damac Properties' Hussain Sajwani and the Surfside condo collapse site (Damac Properties, Getty Images, iStock)
    Year since deadly collapse marked by condo reforms, new development in Surfside
    Year since deadly collapse marked by condo reforms, new development in Surfside
    Spot On Ventures' Robin Brown with The Hampton Inn by Hilton (LinkedIn, Hampton Inn)
    Spot On Ventures buys Miami Beach Hilton-branded hotel for $44M
    Spot On Ventures buys Miami Beach Hilton-branded hotel for $44M
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...