Compass created “dummy job” to avoid Realogy finance exec’s non-compete: judge

Finance exec allegedly attended high-level meetings before jumping to Compass

National /
Sep.September 04, 2019 05:52 PM
Compass CEO Robert Reffkin and Realogy CEO Ryan Schneider

Compass CEO Robert Reffkin and Realogy CEO Ryan Schneider

Compass created a “dummy job” for a longtime Realogy finance executive last year in order to circumvent his non-compete, a New Jersey judge ruled.

At a hearing last month, Judge Maritza Berdote-Byrne said Realogy had provided “convincing evidence” that the SoftBank-backed firm hired Urvin Pandya even though doing so violated a non-compete with Realogy, according to a transcript for the August 14 court appearance obtained by The Real Deal.

According to the transcript, the judge cited an email exchange between Compass recruiters, in which they described Pandya’s new job as a “dummy job created by Finance to hire Urvin.”

She also cited a high-level meeting with Realogy executives that Pandya attended before he quit. He was present at the meeting, she said, knowing full well he was about to resign and take a job at Compass. “I do find that that’s proprietary information,” she said.

“We welcome the best talent to Compass everyday, but we never want confidential information from a prior employers,” a spokesperson for Compass said in a statement. “In fact, all employees are specifically instructed not to bring a previous employer’s confidential information or intellectual property to Compass and sign agreements affirming their understanding of those requirements.”

Compass created “dummy job” to avoid Realogy finance exec’s non-compete: judge

The ruling stems from a lawsuit Realogy filed in May, alleging Pandya stole privileged information from Realogy and shared it with Compass. Realogy also claimed Pandya violated his non-compete, which prevented him from working for a rival within 50 miles of Realogy’s New Jersey offices for six months. Officially, Pandya worked in Philadelphia but he reported to Compass’ CFO in Manhattan.

At an initial hearing in June, a New Jersey judge sidelined Pandya from his new job. She upheld that ruling at the August 14 hearing.

During the August court appearance, an attorney for Pandya and Compass disputed they violated Pandya’s non-compete.

“It’s not as if Compass is a company that just thumbs its nose at the non-compete,” he said.

The judge interrupted his argument. “The email attached… admits to creating this dummy position,” she said. “It’s not a smoking gun, but it’s about as close as you get.”

In justifying her decision, she said Compass was “complicit” in accepting privileged information that Pandya shared with brokerage executives. The firm “was very interested in hiring Mr. Pandya, so much so that they were creative in creating a position for Mr. Pandya, a dummy position, and then consciously discussing how to circumvent the 50-mile geographical restriction of the RCA by putting him in Philadelphia.”

The suit is separate from the wide-ranging lawsuit Realogy filed in July, in which it accused Compass of “predatory” poaching and unfair business practices, including attempts at price-fixing. Pandya is one of the examples in that suit, which claims he had “virtually unfettered access to Realogy’s confidential business information.”


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Compass shares plummet, then recover in volatile morning after lockup ends
Compass shares plummet, then recover in volatile morning after lockup ends
Compass shares plummet, then recover in volatile morning after lockup ends
Howard Hanna CEO Helen Hanna Casey and Compass CEO Robert Reffkin (Howard Hanna Casey, Getty)
Howard Hanna accuses Compass of poaching agents, stealing trade secrets
Howard Hanna accuses Compass of poaching agents, stealing trade secrets
Softbank CEO Masayoshi Son and Compass CEO Robert Reffkin (Getty, Compass)
SoftBank buys $72M of Compass stock
SoftBank buys $72M of Compass stock
Compass CEO Robert Reffkin and agent Ronita Kalra (Photos via Twitter, iStock)
For Compass agents who invested, IPO is watershed moment
For Compass agents who invested, IPO is watershed moment
Clockwise from left: Ori Allon, Robert Citrone, Robert Reffkin and Masayoshi Son (Getty/Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
Here’s who made bank in Compass’ IPO
Here’s who made bank in Compass’ IPO
(Compass/Instagram)
Compass makes public market debut at $7B valuation
Compass makes public market debut at $7B valuation
Robert Reffkin and Ori Allon (Getty, iStock)
What you need to know about Compass’ IPO this week
What you need to know about Compass’ IPO this week
Redfin CEO Glenn Kelman, Compass CEO Robert Reffkin and eXp CEO Jason Gesing. (Getty, Redfin, eXp)
Compass, eXp rise in Real Trends’ annual brokerage rankings
Compass, eXp rise in Real Trends’ annual brokerage rankings
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...