Real estate bigwigs get into fistfight at Hamptons hotspot

Attorney blames one combatant’s “escalating and unacceptable behavior”

Oct.October 08, 2019 03:20 PM
Andrew Saunders and Jeff Colle (Credit: Hampton's Real Estate, Facebook, and iStock)

Andrew Saunders and Jeff Colle (Credit: Hampton’s Real Estate, Facebook, and iStock)

Two East End real estate bigwigs got into a bare-knuckle brawl at a Hamptons hotspot last week.

Andrew Saunders, founder and CEO of the brokerage Saunders & Associates, and Jeffrey Colle — the luxury homebuilder known for developing homes for the likes of Jay-Z and Beyonce — got into a “violent fistfight” at the East Hampton Grill Thursday evening, sources told The Real Deal.

East Hampton Grill

East Hampton Grill

One source said the incident ended with the two men rolling around on the floor punching each other. Another source said Saunders was seated with his party at the restaurant when Colle appeared at the venue and allegedly began to attack him.

The cause of the altercation couldn’t be immediately determined, but sources said Saunders has sold homes for Colle in the past.

Saunders referred TRD to his attorney, Anthony LaPinta, who said he and his client “will pursue all necessary means to stop Mr. Colle’s escalating and unacceptable behavior.”

Joseph Conway, an attorney for Colle, said his client will be arraigned on misdemeanor assault charges on Thursday. He said the whole thing “is being blown out of proportion” and the he and his client will be “prepared to answer these baseless charges in court.”

A representative for the East Hampton Grill, the popular eatery owned by the Hillstone Restaurant Group, declined to comment and referred questions to the East Hampton Village police department. No one at the department was immediately available to discuss the incident.

Saunders, who also develops homes, founded his namesake brokerage in October 2008. It claims to be the largest residential firm in the Hamptons.

Related Articles


Southampton Town buys 3 properties, farmland development rights for $3.6M

Adam Neumann holding onto Hamptons homes amid WeWork woes

The Hamptons see an uptick in fall rentals, report finds

Large swath of developable East Hampton land heading to auction

Affordable housing complex in Southampton officially opens

Jeffrey Collé and Andrew Saunders (Credit: Hampton’s Real Estate, Facebook, and iStock)

Hamptons builder pleads not guilty to assaulting Andrew Saunders

Michael Davis-designed home in Sagaponack sells for $15M after price chop

Ex-Cleveland Browns owner in legal battle over felled trees on Amagansett property