NJ order tapping security deposits to pay rent is back in court

Gov. Phil Murphy’s action is unconstitutional, pro-landlord group tells judges

Tri-State /
Apr.April 07, 2021 05:40 PM
New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy (Getty)

New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy (Getty)

A group that fights big-state policies is restarting its case against New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy on landlords’ behalf.

The New Civil Liberties Alliance argues that Murphy overstepped his authority with an executive order last spring allowing security deposits to be used towards rent. The case was moved to the New Jersey Appellate Court in December to save time.

This week the nonprofit group filed an opening brief arguing that Murphy’s Executive Order No. 128 violated the separation of powers and deprived property owners of due process.

The order, signed a year ago this month, aimed to help renters who lost income during the pandemic. It gives tenants the option to instruct landlords to use security deposits to offset rent without needing to replenish their security deposit until 60 days after the pandemic — which hasn’t ended.

The order maintains tenants’ responsibility to pay for property damage and anything else that the security deposit would cover. But, with the order and an eviction moratorium still in place, NCLA says tenants are taking advantage and leaving landlords to pay out of pocket.

“The landlords and tenants negotiate these contracts upfront to set the incentives … [The order] shifts the incentives and the behaviors of the parties,” said Jared McClain, who represents NCLA in the suit.

After the executive order was issued, a tenant wrote to one of McClain’s landlord clients and asked to use the $2,000 security deposit for rent, McClain said.

The tenant skipped out on last month’s rent, left the apartment with $1,800 worth of damage and disappeared.

“They entered this lease, they agreed to what the rent was going to be, they agreed for a security deposit,” McClain said. “Those were the parameters of the contractual relationship … and the governor unilaterally changed that retroactively.”

Several dozen landlords have reached out to the NCLA with similar stories, saying the order left them struggling to make ends meet or forced them to put rental units up for sale, according to the organization.

Murphy’s office and the New Jersey Tenants Organization did not respond to requests for comment.






    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Judith Nathan, Rudy Giuliani and 353 Lopers Path in Water Mill (Getty, Google Maps)
    Rudy Giuliani’s ex-wife sells Hampton home for $5M
    Rudy Giuliani’s ex-wife sells Hampton home for $5M
    40 Meadow Lane, Nir Meir and Robert Kraft (Google Maps, HFZ, Getty)
    Patriots owner Robert Kraft buys Nir Meir’s Hamptons home for $43M
    Patriots owner Robert Kraft buys Nir Meir’s Hamptons home for $43M
    A rendering of The Pinnacle (Kislak)
    Luxury rental complex in Fort Lee sells for $55M
    Luxury rental complex in Fort Lee sells for $55M
    2468 Kenmore Street in East Meadow (Google Maps)
    Long Island man evades eviction for 20 years
    Long Island man evades eviction for 20 years
    David Walentas and 199 Coopers Neck Lane (Getty, Tim Davis)
    Developer David Walentas lists Hamptons mansion for $35M
    Developer David Walentas lists Hamptons mansion for $35M
    Richard Lefrak and Jersey City (Getty, iStock)
    Neighbors ask Jersey City to change LeFrak’s five-tower project
    Neighbors ask Jersey City to change LeFrak’s five-tower project
    (iStock)
    Long Island sales reach new highs with inventory at record lows
    Long Island sales reach new highs with inventory at record lows
    Progress Capital partner Brad Domenico and Broadacres Office Park (Photos via Progress Capital)
    Bloomfield, NJ office complex sells for $52M
    Bloomfield, NJ office complex sells for $52M
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...